The Grateful Dead: The History of a Folk StoryGerould, Gordon Hall
General
The Grateful Dead: The History of a Folk Story
Gerould, Gordon Hall
Dead -- Folklore; Folk literature -- Themes, motives; Grateful dead (Tale)
As for The Water of Life, there are fewer complications in this
group than in that where the thankful beast does not appear. In all
of the variants some of the fundamental traits of the theme remain
intact. In all save Walewein and Brazilian (which is a degenerate
form presumably carried across the sea by Spaniards or Portuguese)
the three brothers set out from home in quite the normal way. Walewein
again lacks the water of life, which Brazilian retains. All the other
versions, save Tuscan, keep this water or replace it by some other
restorative agency. Two variants only fail to make the older brothers
act treacherously towards the hero, these being again Walewein and
Brazilian. The former thus lacks three of the essentials of the theme,
the latter two. Yet since Walewein makes the hero win his princess
by going on from adventure to adventure quite in the normal manner,
and since Brazilian makes him obtain both water of life and princess,
though with loss of interesting details, we are surely justified in
placing both in this category.
It is worth our while to note in this connection that all these nine
variants come from southern Europe, directly or by derivation. [193]
Geographical proximity, though not sufficient in itself as a basis of
classification, adds welcome confirmation to other proof in cases like
this, where a small group of highly complicated tales is found to exist
in neighbouring countries only. That Walewein can be connected with
this specialized sub-division has important bearings on the question
whence the material for that romance was taken. In view of the limited
territory which this form of the story has covered as a folk-tale
in six hundred years, and the fact that France would be the centre
of the region, it seems fair to assume that some thirteenth century
French writer took a maerchen of his own land as the basis for his work,
thus elaborating with native material the adventures of a Celtic hero.
The question now arises as to what light the group just considered
throws upon the variants which combine the simple theme of The Grateful
Dead with The Water of Life or some such motive. It appeared, the
reader will remember, that according to the elements foreign to the
main motive they must be separated into four classes. Reference to
these classes [194] will show that the variants with The Thankful
Beasts are in many respects different from any one of them as far
as the features peculiar to The Water of Life, or kindred themes,
are concerned. Yet because Maltese and the brief Venetian, though
otherwise transformed, are the only tales aside from these [195] that
preserve the treachery of the hero's brothers, it is safe to class
them together. Both Maltese and Venetian come, it will be observed,
from the same general region as all the other members of the group.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account