The great betrayal (La trahison des clercs)Benda, Julien
Philosophy
The great betrayal (La trahison des clercs)
Benda, Julien
Intellectuals; Nationalism; Philosophy, Modern
I said above that the humanity of the past, more precisely the humanity
of Europe in the Middle Ages, with the values imposed upon it by the
‘clerks’, acted ill but honoured the good. It may be said that modern
Europe with teachers who inform it that its realist instincts are
beautiful, acts ill and honours what is ill. Modern Europe is like
the brigand in one of Tolstoi’s stories, who made his confession to a
hermit, and the hermit said in amazement: ‘Others were at least ashamed
of being brigands; but what is to be done with this man, who is proud
of it?’
Indeed, if we ask ourselves what will happen to a humanity where
every group is striving more eagerly than ever to feel conscious of
its own particular interests, and makes its moralists tell it that it
is sublime to the extent that it knows no law but this interest--a
child can give the answer. This humanity is heading for the greatest
and most perfect war ever seen in the world, whether it is a war of
nations, or a war of classes. A race of which one group exalts one of
its masters (Barrès) to the skies because he teaches: ‘We must defend
the essential part of ourselves as sectarians,’ while a neighbouring
group acclaims a leader because, when he attacks a defenceless small
nation, he says, ‘Necessity knows no law’--such a race is ripe for the
zoological wars Renan talks about, which, he said, would be like the
life and death wars which occur among rodents and among the carnivora.
As regards the nation, think of Italy; as regards class, think of
Russia; and you will see the hitherto unknown point of perfection
attained by the spirit of hatred against what is ‘different’ among
a group of men, consciously realist and at last liberated from all
non-practical morality. And my predictions are not rendered less
probable by the fact that these two nations are hailed as models
throughout the world by those who desire either the grandeur of their
nation or the triumph of their class.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account