The Great Illusion: A Study of the Relation of Military Power to National AdvantageAngell, Norman
History
The Great Illusion: A Study of the Relation of Military Power to National Advantage
Angell, Norman
Commercial policy; Disarmament; Imperialism; War; War, Cost of
Some such view as this has found lurid expression in the recent work of
an American soldier, Homer Lea.[42] The author urges not only that war
is inevitable, but that any systematic attempt to prevent it is merely
an unwise meddling with the universal law.
National entities, in their birth, activities, and death, are
controlled by the same laws that govern all life--plant,
animal, or national--the law of struggle, the law of survival.
These laws, so universal as regards life and time, so
unalterable in causation and consummation, are only variable in
the duration of national existence as the knowledge of and
obedience to them is proportionately true or false. Plans to
thwart them, to shortcut them, to circumvent, to cozen, to
deny, to scorn and violate them, is folly such as man's conceit
alone makes possible. Never has this been tried--and man is
ever at it--but what the end has been gangrenous and fatal.
In theory international arbitration denies the inexorability of
natural laws, and would substitute for them the veriest
Cagliostroic formulas, or would, with the vanity of Canute, sit
down on the ocean-side of life and command the ebb and flow of
its tides to cease.
The idea of international arbitration as a substitute for
natural laws that govern the existence of political entities
arises not only from a denial of their fiats and an ignorance
of their application, but from a total misconception of war,
its causes, and its meaning.
Homer Lea's thesis is emphasized in the introduction to his work,
written by another American soldier, General John P. Storey:
A few idealists may have visions that with advancing
civilization war and its dread horrors will cease. Civilization
has not changed human nature. The nature of man makes war
inevitable. Armed strife will not disappear from the earth
until human nature changes.
"Weltstadt und Friedensproblem," the book of Professor Baron Karl von
Stengel, a jurist who was one of Germany's delegates at the First Hague
Peace Conference, contains a chapter entitled "The Significance of War
for Development of Humanity," in which the author says:
War has more often facilitated than hindered progress. Athens
and Rome, not only in spite of, but just because of their many
wars, rose to the zenith of civilization. Great States like
Germany and Italy are welded into nationalities only through
blood and iron.
Storm purifies the air and destroys the frail trees, leaving
the sturdy oaks standing. War is the test of a nation's
political, physical, and intellectual worth. The State in which
there is much that is rotten may vegetate for a while in peace,
but in war its weakness is revealed.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account