The Great Illusion: A Study of the Relation of Military Power to National AdvantageAngell, Norman
History
The Great Illusion: A Study of the Relation of Military Power to National Advantage
Angell, Norman
Commercial policy; Disarmament; Imperialism; War; War, Cost of
Spain represents the outcome of some centuries devoted mainly
to military activity. No one can say that she has been
unmilitary or at all deficient in those qualities which we
associate with soldiers and soldiering. Yet, if such qualities
in any way make for national efficiency, for the conservation
of national force, the history of Spain is absolutely
inexplicable. In their late contest with America, Spaniards
showed no lack of the distinctive military virtues. Spain's
inferiority--apart from deficiency of men and money--was
precisely in those qualities which industrialism has bred in
the unmilitary American. Authentic stories of wretched
equipment, inadequate supplies, and bad leadership show to what
depths of inefficiency the Spanish service, military and naval,
had fallen. We are justified in believing that a much smaller
nation than Spain, but one possessing a more industrial and
less military training, would have done much better, both as
regards resistance to America and the defence of her own
colonies. The present position of Holland in Asia seems to
prove this. The Dutch, whose traditions are industrial and
non-military for the most part, have shown greater power and
efficiency as a nation than the Spanish, who are more numerous.
Here, as always, it is shown that, in considering national
efficiency, even as expressed in military power, the economic
problem cannot be divorced from the military, and that it is a
fatal mistake to suppose that the power of a nation depends
solely upon the power of its public bodies, or that it can be
judged simply from the size of its army. A large army may,
indeed, be a sign of a national--that is, military--weakness.
Warfare in these days is a business like other activities, and
no courage, no heroism, no "glorious past," no "immortal
traditions," will atone for deficient rations and fraudulent
administration. Good civilian qualities are the ones that will
in the end win a nation's battles. The Spaniard is the last one
in the world to see this. He talks and dreams of Castilian
bravery and Spanish honor, and is above shopkeeping details....
A writer on contemporary Spain remarks that any intelligent
middle-class Spaniard will admit every charge of incompetence
which can be brought against the conduct of public affairs.
"Yes, we have a wretched Government. In any other country
somebody would be shot." This is the hopeless military creed:
killing somebody is the only remedy.
Here we see a trace of that intellectual legacy which Spain has left to
the New World, and which has stamped itself so indelibly on the history
of Spanish America. On a later occasion in this connection I wrote as
follows:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account