The Great Illusion: A Study of the Relation of Military Power to National AdvantageAngell, Norman
History
The Great Illusion: A Study of the Relation of Military Power to National Advantage
Angell, Norman
Commercial policy; Disarmament; Imperialism; War; War, Cost of
For months those in the secrets of the Chancelleries have
spoken with bated breath--as though in the presence of some
vision of Armageddon. On the strength of this mere talk of war
by the three nations, vast commerical interests have been
embarrassed, fortunes have been lost and won on the Bourses,
banks have suspended payment, some thousands have been ruined;
while the fact that the fourth and fifth nations have actually
gone to war has raised all sorts of further possibilities of
conflict, not alone in Europe, but in Asia, with remoter danger
of religious fanaticism and all its sequelæ. International
bitterness and suspicion in general have been intensified, and
the one certain result of the whole thing is that immense
burdens will be added in the shape of further taxation for
armaments to the already heavy ones carried by the five or six
nations concerned. For two or three hundred millions of people
in Europe, life, which with all the problems of high prices,
labor wars, unsolved social difficulties, is none too easy as
it is, will be made harder still.
The needs, therefore, that can have provoked a conflict of
these dimensions must be "primordial" indeed. In fact one
authority assures us that what we have seen going on is "the
struggle for life among men"--that struggle which has its
parallel in the whole of sentient existence.
Well, I put it to you, as a matter worth just a moment or two
of consideration, that this conflict is about nothing of the
sort; that it is about a perfectly futile matter, one which the
immense majority of the German, English, French, Italian, and
Turkish people could afford to treat with the completest
indifference. For, to the vast majority of these 250,000,000
people more or less, it does not matter two straws whether
Morocco or some vague African swamp near the Equator is
administered by German, French, Italian, or Turkish officials,
so long as it is well administered. Or rather one should go
further: if French, German, or Italian colonization of the past
is any guide, the nation which wins in the contest for
territory of this sort has added a wealth-draining incubus.
This, of course, is preposterous; I am losing sight of the need
for making provision for the future expansion of the race, for
each party to "find its place in the sun"; and Heaven knows
what!
The European Press was full of these phrases at the time, and I
attempted to weigh their real meaning by a comparison of French and
German history in the matter of national "expansion" during the last
thirty or forty years.
France has got a new empire, we are told; she has won a great
victory; she is growing and expanding and is richer by
something which her rivals are the poorer for not having.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account