"The Greatest Failure in All History": A Critical Examination of the Actual Workings of Bolshevism in RussiaSpargo, John
History
"The Greatest Failure in All History": A Critical Examination of the Actual Workings of Bolshevism in Russia
Spargo, John
Communism -- Russia
If we had reason to fear last year for the working of our
transport, the complaints of its inefficiency being well
grounded, matters have become considerably worse during the
period under report. Water transport is by no means in a better
position, whilst of haulage transport there is no need to
speak.... The consuming needs of the workmen have not been even
remotely satisfied, either in the last year or in the current
year, by the Commissariat of Food Supply, _the main source of
food-supply of the workmen being speculation and free market_.
But even the latter source of food-supply of the workmen in
manufacturing districts is becoming more and more inaccessible.
Besides the fact that prices have soared up to a much greater
extent than the controlled rates of wages, we see the almost
complete disappearance of food articles from working-center
markets. _Of recent times, even pilgrimage to villages is of
no avail. The villages will not part with food for money even
at high prices._ What they demand is articles of which the
workers are no less in need. Hence the workers’ escape from the
factories (_220_).
Unfortunately, a good many of the concerns enumerated [in the
Tula District] do not work or work only with half the output,
in spite of the fact that 20 of the shafts working yield
considerable quantities of coal, 10 mines supply much raw
material (15 milliard poods of minerals are estimated to be
lying in this district), whilst there is also a large number of
broken lathes and machinery which can, however, be repaired.
Bread for the workers could also be found, if all efforts were
strained (the district used to export corn in peace-time). All
these possibilities are not carried into life, as there are
no people who could by their intense will and sincere desire
restore the iron discipline of labor. Our institutions are
filled with “Sovburs” and “Speks,” who only think of their own
welfare and not of the welfare of the state and of making use
of the revolutionary possibilities of the “toilers in revolt.”
In the light of this terrible evidence we can readily believe what
Zinoviev wrote in an article contributed to the _Severnaya Communa_ in
January of this year. In that article he said: “King Famine seems to
be putting out his tongue at the proletariat of Petrograd and their
families.... Of late I have been receiving, one after another, starving
delegations from working men and women. They do not protest, nor do
they make any demands; they merely point out, with silent reproach, the
present intolerable state of affairs.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account