"The Greatest Failure in All History": A Critical Examination of the Actual Workings of Bolshevism in RussiaSpargo, John
History
"The Greatest Failure in All History": A Critical Examination of the Actual Workings of Bolshevism in Russia
Spargo, John
Communism -- Russia
This experiment is of the most vital moral and material
importance. We cannot mobilize the peasants by means of
trades-unions, and the trades-unions themselves do not possess
any means of laying hold of millions of peasants. They can best
be mobilized on a military footing. Their labor formations will
have to be organized on a military model--labor platoons, labor
companies, labor battalions, disciplined as required, for we
shall have to deal with masses which have not passed through
trades-union trading. This is a matter of the near future. We
shall be compelled to create military organizations such as
exist already in the form of our armies. It is therefore urgent
to utilize them by adapting them to economic requirements. That
is exactly what we are doing now.
At the ninth Congress of the Communist Party in March, according to
_Izvestia_ of March 21, 1920, Trotsky made another report on the
militarization of labor, in which he said:
At the present time the militarization of labor is all the more
needed in that we have now come to the mobilization of peasants
as the means of solving the problems requiring mass action.
We are mobilizing the peasants and forming them into labor
detachments which very closely resemble military detachments.
Some of our comrades say, however, that even though in the case
of the working power of mobilized peasantry it is necessary to
apply militarization, a military apparatus need not be created
when the question involves skilled labor and industry because
there we have professional unions performing the function of
organizing labor. This opinion, however, is erroneous.
At present it is true that professional unions distribute labor
power at the demand of social-economic organizations, but what
means and methods do they possess for insuring that the workman
who is sent to a given factory actually reports at that factory
for work?
We have in the most important branches of our industry more
than a million workmen on the lists, but not more than eight
hundred thousand of them are actually working, and where are
the remainder? They have gone to the villages, or to other
divisions of industry, or into speculation. Among soldiers this
is called desertion, and in one form or another the measures
used to compel soldiers to do their duty should be applied in
the field of labor.
_Under a unified system of economy the masses of workmen should
be moved about, ordered and sent from place to place in exactly
the same manner as soldiers. This is the foundation of the
militarization of labor, and without this we are unable to
speak seriously of any organization of industry on a new basis
in the conditions of starvation and disorganization existing
to-day...._
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account