"The Greatest Failure in All History": A Critical Examination of the Actual Workings of Bolshevism in RussiaSpargo, John
History
"The Greatest Failure in All History": A Critical Examination of the Actual Workings of Bolshevism in Russia
Spargo, John
Communism -- Russia
In May, 1918, the city of Korocha was the scene of a horrible
massacre. Thirty officers, four priests, and three hundred
citizens were killed.
In May, 1918, the relations of the Soviet Government to the peasantry
were described by Gorky as the war of the city against the country.
They were, in fact, very similar to the relations of conquering
armies to the subjugated but rebellious and resentful populations of
conquered territories. On May 14th a decree was issued regarding the
control of grain, the famous compulsory grain registration order. This
decree occupies so important a place in the history of the struggle,
and contains so many striking features, that a fairly full summary is
necessary:[9]
[9] The entire text is given as an appendix at the end of the volume.
While the people in the consuming districts are starving,
there are large reserves of unthreshed grain in the producing
districts. This grain is in the hands of the village
bourgeoisie--“tight-fisted village dealers and profiteers”--who
remain “deaf and indifferent to the wailings of starving
workmen and peasant poverty” and hold their grain in the hope
of forcing the government to raise the price of grain, selling
only to the speculators at fabulous prices. “An end must be
put to this obstinacy of the greedy village grain-profiteers.”
To abolish the grain monopoly and the system of fixed prices,
while it would lessen the profits of one group of capitalists,
would also “make bread completely inaccessible to our many
millions of workmen and would subject them to inevitable death
from starvation.” Only food grains absolutely necessary for
feeding their families, on a rationed basis, and for seed
purposes should be permitted to be held by the peasants. “_The
answer to the violence of grain-growers toward the starving
poor must be violence toward the bourgeoisie._”
Continuing its policy of price-fixing and monopolization of the
grain-supply, the government decreed “a merciless struggle with
grain speculators,” compulsion of “each grain-owner to declare the
surplus above what is needed to sow the fields and for personal use,
according to established normal quantities, until the new harvest,
and to surrender the same within a week after the publication of this
decision in each village.” The workmen and poor peasants were called
upon “to unite at once for a merciless struggle with grain-hoarders.”
All persons having a surplus of grain and failing to bring it to the
collecting-points, and those wasting grain on illicit distillation of
alcohol, were to be regarded as “enemies of the people.” They were to
be turned over to the Revolutionary Tribunal, which would “imprison
them for ten years, confiscate their entire property, and drive them
out forever from the communes”; while the distillers must, in addition,
“be condemned to compulsory communal work.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account