"The Greatest Failure in All History": A Critical Examination of the Actual Workings of Bolshevism in RussiaSpargo, John
History
"The Greatest Failure in All History": A Critical Examination of the Actual Workings of Bolshevism in Russia
Spargo, John
Communism -- Russia
The Russian peasant could, in all fairness, scarcely be
suspected of being a capitalist, and even according to the
Soviet constitution, no matter how twisted, he could not be
denied a vote. But fully aware that the peasants constitute
a majority and are, as a whole, opposed to the Bolsheviki,
the latter have destroyed the Soviets in the villages and
instead of these they have created so-called “Committees of
the Poor”--_i.e._, aggregations of inebriates, propertyless,
worthless, and work-hating peasants. For, whoever wishes to
work can find work in the Russian village which is always short
of agricultural help. These “Committees of the Poor” have been
delegated to represent the peasantry of Russia.
Small wonder that the peasants are opposed to this scheme which
has robbed them of self-government. Small wonder that their
hatred for these “organizations” reaches such a stage that
entire settlements are rising against these Soviets and their
pretorians, the Red Guardsmen, and in their fury are not only
murdering these Soviet officials, but are practising fearful
cruelties upon them, as happened in December, 1918, in the
Governments of Pskov, Kaluga, and Tver.
By removing and arresting all those delegates who are
undesirable to them, the Bolsheviki have converted these
Soviets into organizations loyal to themselves, and, of course,
fear to think of a true general election, for that will seal
their doom at once.
Mr. Eroshkin, like practically every other leader of the Russian
peasants’ movement, is an anti-Bolshevik and his testimony may be
regarded as biased. Let us, therefore, consider what Bolshevist writers
have said in their own press.
_Izvestia_ of the Provincial Soviets, January 18, 1919, published the
following:
The Commissaries were going through the Tzaritzin County in
sumptuous carriages, driven by three, and often by six, horses.
A great array of adjutants and a large suite accompanied these
Commissaries and an imposing number of trunks followed along.
They made exorbitant demands upon the toiling population,
coupled with assaults and brutality. Their way of squandering
money right and left is particularly characteristic. In some
houses the Commissaries gambled away and spent on intoxicants
large sums. The hard-working population looked upon these
orgies as upon complete demoralization and failure of duty to
the world revolution.
In the same official journal, four days later, January 22, 1919,
Kerzhentzev, the well-known Bolshevik, wrote:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account