"The Greatest Failure in All History": A Critical Examination of the Actual Workings of Bolshevism in RussiaSpargo, John
History
"The Greatest Failure in All History": A Critical Examination of the Actual Workings of Bolshevism in Russia
Spargo, John
Communism -- Russia
Help! we are perishing! At the time when we are starving do
you know what is going on in the villages? Take, for instance,
our village, Olkhi. Speculation is rife there, especially with
salt, which sells at 40 rubles a pound. What does the militia
do? What do the Soviets do? When it is reported to them they
wave their hands and say, “This is a normal phenomenon.” Not
only this, but the militiamen, beginning with the chief and
including some communists, are all engaged in brewing their
own alcohol, which sells for 70 rubles a bottle. Nobody who is
in close touch with the militia is afraid to engage in this
work. Hunger is ahead of us, but neither the citizens nor the
“authorities” recognize it. The people’s judge also drinks,
and if one wishes to win a case one only needs to treat him
to a drink. We live in a terrible filth. There is no soap.
People and horses all suffer from skin diseases. Epidemics are
inevitable in the summer. If Moscow will pay no attention to
us, then we shall perish. _We had elections for the village and
county Soviets, but the voting occurred in violation of the
Constitution of the Soviet Government._
_As a result of this a number of village capitalists, who,
under the guise of communists, entered the party in order to
avoid the requisitions and contributions, were elected._ The
laboring peasantry is thus being turned against the government,
and this at a time when the hosts of Kolchak are advancing from
the east.
Lenin, in his report to the Eighth Congress of the Communist Party last
April, published in _Pravda_, April 9, 1919, faced the seriousness of
the situation indicated by these reports. He said:
All class-conscious workmen, of Petrograd, Ivano-Voznesensk,
and Moscow, who have been in the villages, tell us of instances
of many misunderstandings, of misunderstandings that could not
be solved, it seemed, _and of conflicts of the most serious
nature_, all of which were, however, solved by sensible workmen
who did not speak according to the book, but in language which
the people could understand, and not like an officer allowing
himself to issue orders, though unacquainted with village life,
but like a comrade explaining the situation and appealing
to their feelings as toilers. And by such explanation one
attained what could not be attained by thousands who conducted
themselves like commanders or superiors.
In the _Severnaya Communa_, May 10, 1919, another Bolshevist official,
Krivoshayev, reported:
The Soviet workers are taking from the peasants chicken, geese,
bread, and butter without paying for it. In some households
of these poverty-stricken folk they are confiscating even the
pillows and the samovars and everything they can lay their
hands on. The peasants naturally feel very bitterly toward the
Soviet rule.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account