"The Greatest Failure in All History": A Critical Examination of the Actual Workings of Bolshevism in RussiaSpargo, John
History
"The Greatest Failure in All History": A Critical Examination of the Actual Workings of Bolshevism in Russia
Spargo, John
Communism -- Russia
Here one must have practical experience and knowledge of
local conditions, and we have not these things as yet. We are
not at all ashamed to admit this; we must admit this openly.
We have never been Utopists and have never imagined that we
could build up the communistic society with the pure hands
of pure communists who would be born and educated in a pure
communistic society. Such would be children’s fables. We must
build communism on the ruins of capitalism, and only that class
which has been tempered in the struggle against capitalism
can do this. You know very well that the proletariat is not
without the faults and weaknesses of the capitalistic society.
It struggles for Socialism, and at the same time against its
own defects. The best and most progressive portion of the
proletariat which has been carrying on a desperate struggle in
the cities for decades was able to imitate in the course of
this struggle all the culture of city life, and to a certain
extent did acquire it. You know that the village even in the
most progressive countries was condemned to ignorance. Of
course, the cultural level of the village will be raised by
us, but that is a matter of years and years. This is what
our comrades everywhere forget, and this is what every word
that comes to us from the village portrays with particular
clearness, when the word comes not from local intellectuals and
local officials, but from people who are watching the work in
the village from a practical point of view.
* * * * *
When we speak of the tasks in connection with work in the
villages, in spite of all difficulties, in spite of the
fact that our knowledge has been directed to the immediate
suppression of exploiters, we must nevertheless remember and
not forget that in the villages with relation to the middle
peasantry the task is of a different nature. All conscious
workmen, of Petrograd, Ivanovo-Vosnesensk, and Moscow, who
have been in the villages, tell us of instances of many
misunderstandings, of misunderstandings that could not be
solved, it seemed, and of conflicts of the most serious nature,
all of which were, however, solved by sensible workmen who did
not speak according to the book, but in language which the
people could understand, and not like an officer allowing
himself to issue orders though unacquainted with village life,
but like a comrade explaining the situation and appealing
to their feelings as toilers. And by such explanation one
attained what could not be attained by thousands who conducted
themselves like commanders or superiors.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account