The Greek Philosophers, Vol. 1 (of 2)Benn, Alfred William
Philosophy
The Greek Philosophers, Vol. 1 (of 2)
Benn, Alfred William
Philosophy, Ancient
There is, perhaps, no passage in Aristotle’s writings—there is
certainly none in his scientific writings—more eloquent than that
which describes the glory of his imaginary heavens. The following
translation may give some faint idea of its solemnity and splendour:—
We believe, then, that the whole heaven is one and everlasting,
without beginning or end through all eternity, but holding infinite
time within its orb; not, as some say, created or capable of being
destroyed. We believe it on account of the grounds already stated,
and also on account of the consequences resulting from a different
hypothesis. For, it must add great weight to our assurance of its
immortality and everlasting duration that this opinion may, while the
contrary opinion cannot possibly, be true. Wherefore, we may trust
the traditions of old time, and especially of our own race, when
they tell us that there is something deathless and divine about the
things which, although moving, have a movement that is not bounded,
but is itself the universal bound, a perfect circle enclosing in its
revolutions the imperfect motions that are subject to restraint and
arrest; while this, being without beginning or end or rest through
infinite time, is the one from which all others originate, and into
which they disappear. That heaven which antiquity assigned to the
gods as an immortal abode, is shown by the present argument to be
uncreated and indestructible, exempt alike from mortal weakness and
from the weariness of subjection to a force acting in opposition
to its natural inclination; for in proportion to its everlasting
continuance such a compulsion would be laborious, and unparticipant in
the highest perfection of design. We must not, then, believe with the
old mythologists that an Atlas is needed to uphold it; for they, like
some in more recent times, fancied that the heavens were made of heavy
earthy matter, and so fabled an animated necessity for their support;
nor yet that, as Empedocles says, they will last only so long as
their own proper momentum is exceeded by the whirling motion of which
they partake.[255] Nor, again, is it likely that their everlasting
revolution can be kept up by the exercise of a conscious will; for
no soul could lead a happy and blessed existence that was engaged in
such a task, necessitating, as it would, an unceasing struggle with
their native tendency to move in a different direction, without even
the mental relaxation and bodily rest which mortals gain by sleep, but
doomed to the eternal torment of an Ixion’s wheel. Our explanation,
on the other hand, is, as we say, not only more consistent with the
eternity of the heavens, but also can alone be reconciled with the
acknowledged vaticinations of religious faith.[256]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account