The Grenadier Guards in the Great War of 1914-1918, Vol. 3 of 3Ponsonby, Frederick
History
The Grenadier Guards in the Great War of 1914-1918, Vol. 3 of 3
Ponsonby, Frederick
Great Britain. Army. Grenadier Guards; World War, 1914-1918 -- Regimental histories -- Great Britain
"I respectfully beg to bring to your notice, and to strongly
protest against, what I consider is an usurpation of the
rights and privileges of the Regiment under my command, by
the establishment of 'GRENADIERS' to all battalions
of the Army by Army Order of the 11th October 1915, and would
venture to suggest that the name of 'GRENADIERS'
given to Regimental Bomb Throwers be altered to
'BOMBERS.'
"In the _London Gazette_ of 29th July 1815 the First Regiment
of Foot Guards had bestowed upon it the title of 'First or
Grenadier Regiment of Foot Guards' in commemoration of their
having defeated the Grenadiers of the French Imperial Guard at
the Battle of Waterloo.
"This distinction the Regiment has proudly borne for the past
100 years, and it is a source of regret to all ranks that at
this period, when there are four battalions of the Regiment
upon Active Service, this title, which was granted exclusively
to the Grenadier Guards as a reward for services in the Field,
should in any way be invalidated."
On receipt of Colonel Streatfeild's protest, Lord Cavan wrote to
General Headquarters:
"I beg with great deference to raise a question of privilege.
The word and title Grenadier is now seen in all official
documents to denote a man who throws a bomb. This title was
given to the First Guards for service rendered at Waterloo,
and they are naturally jealous of the honour."
"In conversation the word bomber is general, but if this is
not sufficiently dignified for official documents I most
respectfully suggest that 'bomb thrower' be the recognised
title."
To this the Adjutant-General at General Headquarters in France sent the
following reply:
"The term bomb is officially confined to projectiles fired
from trench mortars or dropped from aeroplanes. Projectiles
thrown by hand are 'grenades.'
"The G.O.C. Guards Division is in error in supposing that
the Grenadier Guards are the only Regiment in which the word
grenadier forms part of the title of the Regiment.
"It would appear that the term Grenadiers is merely an
unofficial abbreviation of Grenadier Guards, and does not
appear in any official documents in relation to that Regiment.
"The Grenade fired proper is the badge of many Regiments,
and it would seem that a claim to the sole use of the title
'Grenadier' has as little foundation as one to be the only
wearers of the Grenade badge.
"It would seem that Modern Warfare has necessitated a partial
return to the Grenadier Companies of former days which it is
believed existed without any prejudice to the rights of the
Grenadier Guards."
Lord Cavan, however, could not let the matter rest there, and again
wrote to the Adjutant-General on December 22, meeting the arguments put
forward by him. He said:
"I beg respectfully to reply to the remarks of the A.G.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account