Jewish philosophy -- Early works to 1800; Judaism -- Works to 1900; Philosophy, Medieval -- Early works to 1800
expression “more than” is used in comparing two things as regards a
certain attribute predicated of both of them in exactly the same sense,
and consequently implies similarity [between God and His creatures].
When they ascribe to God essential attributes, these so-called
essential attributes should not have any similarity to the attributes
of other things, and should according to their own opinion not be
included in one of the same definition, just as there is no similarity
between the essence of God and that of other beings. They do not follow
this principle, for they hold that one definition may include them, and
that, nevertheless, there is no similarity between them. Those who are
familiar with the meaning of similarity will certainly understand that
the term existence, when applied to God and to other beings, is
perfectly homonymous. In like manner, the terms Wisdom, Power, Will,
and Life are applied to God and to other beings by way of perfect
homonymity, admitting of no comparison whatever. Nor must you think
that these attributes are employed as hybrid terms; for hybrid terms
are such as are applied to two things which have a similarity to each
other in respect to a certain property which is in both of them an
accident, not an essential, constituent element. The attributes of God,
however, are not considered as accidental by any intelligent person,
while all attributes applied to man are accidents, according to the
Mutakallemim. I am therefore at a loss to see how they can find any
similarity [between the attributes of God and those of man]; how their
definitions can be identical, and their significations the same! This
is a decisive proof that there is, in no way or sense, anything common
to the attributes predicated of God, and those used in reference to
ourselves; they have only the same names, and nothing else is common to
them. Such being the case, it is not proper to believe, on account of
the use of the same attributes, that there is in God something
additional to His essence, in the same way as attributes are joined to
our essence. This is most important for those who understand it. Keep
it in memory, and study it thoroughly, in order to be well prepared for
that which I am going to explain to you.
CHAPTER LVII
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account