Jewish philosophy -- Early works to 1800; Judaism -- Works to 1900; Philosophy, Medieval -- Early works to 1800
According to Proposition XXV., a moving agent must exist which has
moved the substance of all existing transient things and enabled it to
receive Form. The cause of the motion of that agent is found in the
existence of another motor of the same or of a different class, the
term “motion,” in a general sense, being common to four categories
(Prop. IV.). This series of motions is not infinite (Prop. III.); we
find that it can only be continued till the motion of the fifth element
is arrived at, and then it ends. The motion of the fifth element is the
source of every force that moves and prepares any substance on earth
for its combination with a certain form, and is connected with that
force by a chain of intermediate motions. The celestial sphere [or the
fifth element] performs the act of locomotion which is the first of the
several kinds of motion (Prop. XIV.), and all locomotion is found to be
the indirect effect of the motion of this sphere; e.g., a stone is set
in motion by a stick, the stick by a man’s hand, the hand by the
sinews, the sinews by the muscles, the muscles by the nerves, the
nerves by the natural heat of the body, and the heat of the body by its
form. This is undoubtedly the immediate motive cause, but the action of
this immediate cause is due to a certain design, e.g., to bring a stone
into a hole by striking against it with a stick in order to prevent the
draught from coming through the crevice. The motion of the air that
causes the draught is the effect of the motion of the celestial sphere.
Similarly it may be shown that the ultimate cause of all genesis and
destruction can be traced to the motion of the sphere. But the motion
of the sphere must likewise have been effected by an agent (Prop.
XVII.) residing either without the sphere or within it; a third case
being impossible. In the first case, if the motor is without the
sphere, it must either be corporeal or incorporeal; if incorporeal, it
cannot be said that the agent is without the sphere; it can only be
described as separate from it; because an incorporeal object can only
be said metaphorically to reside without a certain corporeal object. In
the second case, if the agent resides within the sphere, it must be
either a force distributed throughout the whole sphere so that each
part of the sphere includes a part of the force, as is the case with
the heat of fire; or it is an indivisible force, e.g., the soul and the
intellect (Props. X. and XI.). The agent which sets the sphere in
motion must consequently be one of the following four things: a
corporeal object without the sphere; an incorporeal object separate
from it; a force spread throughout the whole of the sphere; or an
indivisible force [within the sphere].
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account