The Historical Jesus: A Survey of PositionsRobertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Religion
The Historical Jesus: A Survey of Positions
Robertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Jesus Christ -- Historicity; Jesus Christ -- Rationalistic interpretations
Professor Schmiedel's careful argument from "derogatory" episodes
in the gospel of Mark, be it repeated, is not merely inconclusive;
it elicits a rebuttal which turns it into a defeat. Inadequate even
on the textual side, it is wholly fallacious on the hierological
and the mythological; and no more than the ordinary conservative
polemic does it recognize the sociological problem involved. For
those who seek to study history comprehensively and comprehendingly,
the residuum of the conservative case is a blank incredibility. Even
Dalman, after the closest linguistic and literary analysis, has
left the meaning of "the Kingdom of God" a conundrum; [38] and the
conservative case finally consists in asserting that Christianity
as a public movement arose in the simple announcement of that
conundrum--the mere utterance of the formula--throughout Palestine
by a body of twelve apostles, who for the rest "cast out devils,"
as instructed by their Teacher. The "scholarship" which contentedly
rests facing that vacuous conception is a scholarship not qualified
finally to handle a great historical problem as such. It conducts
itself exactly as did Biblical scholarship so long in face of the
revelations of geology, and as did Hebrew scholarship so long over
the problem of the Tabernacle in the wilderness.
Deeply learned men, in the latter case, went on for generations
solemnly re-writing history in the terms of the re-arranged documents,
when all the while the history was historic myth--perceptible as such
to a Zulu who had lived in a desert. And when the Zulu's teacher proved
the case by simple arithmetic, he met at the hands alike of pedants
and of pietists a volley of malignant vituperation, the "religious"
expert Maurice excelling many of the most orthodox in the virulence of
his scorn; while the pontifical Arnold, from the Olympian height of his
amateurism, severely lectured Colenso for not having written in Latin.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account