The History of Antiquity, Vol. 5 (of 6)Duncker, Max
History
The History of Antiquity, Vol. 5 (of 6)
Duncker, Max
History, Ancient
Setting aside any conclusions of this kind, even tradition can only have
regarded the beginning of the struggle for freedom as the beginning of
liberation, if it covered the nucleus of a firm resistance, either in
some definite district, or in a dynasty which took the lead in the
struggle and carried it on. Herodotus is not acquainted with any leader
in the struggle and does not mention any, while the campaigns of the
Assyrians are always directed against a greater or less number of
princes and cities; sometimes they fall on this chieftain and sometimes
on that.[477] If, moreover, the fact that Sargon receives tribute from
twenty-five, then from twenty-two, and then from forty-five chieftains,
is brought forward to confirm the narratives of Herodotus about the
anarchy which prevailed among the Medes, it is not the separation of the
Medes under different chiefs which constitutes the anarchy as described
by Herodotus, but actual lawlessness. His description gives us no
chieftains in Media, ruling their lands as captains in war and judges in
peace. The Medes dwell in villages, and the inhabitants choose the
village judge, though it is in their power to go for decision to another
village. Chieftains, even if they had not forbidden their tribes to seek
for justice out of the tribe, would in any case have left the decision
of Deioces unnoticed.
However this may be, one harsh contradiction between the narrative of
Herodotus and the inscriptions cannot be removed by any exposition or
any deductions. According to Herodotus Deioces reigned from the year 708
to 655 B.C., Phraortes from 655 to 633 B.C., over the whole of Media.
The inscriptions of Sennacherib mention the great payment of tribute by
the distant land of Media, and its subjugation under Sennacherib (p.
282); Esarhaddon removes two chieftains with their flocks and subjects
out of Media from the border of the land of Bikni to Asshur, and three
chiefs from the same district bring their tribute to Nineveh; he places
his viceroys over them, and they unite this district with Assyria. After
the year 660 B.C. Assurbanipal is said to have taken a chieftain of
Media captive; and in the inscriptions there is nowhere any mention of
Deioces, Phraortes, and the Median kingdom.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account