When, however, four persons were found going to the house of one, for the purpose of forcing him to fight a duel, though the duel might be conducted most fairly, according to the laws of honour, it was murder, under certain circumstances, in the eye of the law. Mr. Cuddie received the ball fired from the pistol of William Brittlebank; he was then carried into the kitchen, he believed, by Spencer and Andrew Brittlebank. What followed would be proved by witnesses; and he expected it would be proved, that Andrew Brittlebank had at first denied having been present; but when the deceased stated him to be there, he then said, “Well, since you say so, did I not try to prevent the duel, by pressing you to offer something in the shape of an apology?” William Brittlebank had said, that the deceased must consider Spencer as his friend; and it would be shown, that when Cuddie, in a dying state, had been pressed to declare the duel had been a fair one, he declined doing so, though aware of his situation, sometimes by expressions, and at others by actions of dissent, such as shaking his head; and he certainly died without any such admission. Should the evidence fail to make out the charge, those concerned for the prosecution would be most happy to hear of a verdict of acquittal: should the facts be proved, their righteous verdict must be given; and, painful as it might be to themselves and all who heard it, they would have but one duty to perform. A variety of witnesses were called, who proved the circumstances under which Mr. Cuddie lost his life. It appeared that he had received much provocation; but it appeared that the prisoners had endeavoured to give him every assistance after he received the wound. The following is a copy of the declaration made by Mr. Cuddie on his death-bed:— “The declaration of William Cuddie, of Winster, surgeon, made before me, Philip Gell, Esq., one of his Majesty’s justices of the peace for the county of Derby, this 22nd day of May, 1821, who saith, that he was called upon by William Brittlebank, of Winster, to fight a duel, and that he wished to avoid doing so. That Edmund Spencer, of Bakewell, surgeon, came to him on the 22nd of May, instant, and told him that William Brittlebank and his brothers were in the garden waiting for him, and that he, William Cuddie, must make an apology, or fight. That he, William Cuddie, went to the garden, and refused to make an apology. That Edmund Spencer opened his coat and showed him two pistols, one of which he took, and William Brittlebank took the other; that they separated to the distance of fifteen yards, or more. That Edmund Spencer threw up his hat as a signal, and they both fired their pistols as near together as possible.”