The history of our Navy from its origin to the present day, 1775-1897, vol. 2 (of 4)Spears, John Randolph
History
The history of our Navy from its origin to the present day, 1775-1897, vol. 2 (of 4)
Spears, John Randolph
United States. Navy -- History; United States. Navy -- History -- Spanish-American War, 1898
To make this matter of the relative efficiency in that day of
the English and American naval seamen still clearer, it is worth
considering the size of the target at which the Englishmen fired and
missed so often. The _United States_ stood as high out of water as
the second-story windows of ordinary dwellings in any of the large
American cities. She was as long as the combined fronts of, say seven
houses, standing in a solid row. Incredible as it may seem, it is
really a fact, that although the _Macedonian_ was no further away than
across the street from this big target, and fired repeatedly at that
range with the whole broadside, she only landed three shot in the
target. Now what kind of gunners were they that they couldn’t hit a
two-story house when firing at “half pistol-shot” range?
It was not for lack of practice either, for Executive Officer David
Hope, under the date of June 22, 1824, wrote that “in no ship in
the British service could there have been more attention paid to
the practical part of gunnery than was done to the crew of the
_Macedonian_. The men were not only well trained, but the greatest
attention was paid to every department relating to the guns.” That was
in 1812. They do things in different fashion in the British navy now,
and they know how to shoot guns and how to hit targets as well.
It is interesting at this point to recall a remark made by Captain
Carden of the _Macedonian_ when dining on board the _United States_ at
Norfolk before the war. He had been pointing out the superiority of
such frigates as the _Macedonian_ to any others afloat--had told how
much more rapidly and accurately their long eighteens could be handled
than the American’s long twenty-fours--how much more metal they would
drive into an enemy in a given time and how much handier in every way
the _Macedonian_ was than the _United States_, when he closed by saying:
“Besides, Decatur, though your ship may be good enough, and you are a
clever set of fellows, what practice have you had in war? There is the
rub!”
The truth is, as was said in telling of the _Constitution-Guerrière_
fight, the British Lords of Admiralty knew all about the size of the
_Constitution_, the _United States_ and all the rest of the American
ships. They knew the number and size of guns carried. The _United
States_ was launched at Philadelphia on July 10, 1797. She had been
afloat fifteen years when she whipped the _Macedonian_, and the
_Constitution_, her sister-ship, had been afloat but a few weeks less.
The British officers had often inspected them, and yet through their
obstinate faith in the superiority of their own knowledge they built
the _Macedonian_ in 1810, fully believing she was a fair match for any
frigate afloat! After the war of 1812 had taught them something they
built their frigates on “exactly the same plan” of the long-despised
model of Joshua Humphreys, the Philadelphia Quaker.
[Illustration: Stephen Decatur.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account