The History of the Manners and Customs of Ancient Greece, Volume 1 (of 3)St. John, James Augustus
History
The History of the Manners and Customs of Ancient Greece, Volume 1 (of 3)
St. John, James Augustus
Greece -- Social life and customs
Before the young man could reply to this compliment the sophist
proceeded:
“Answer me, Ctesippos, a little longer. Do you ever beat that dog?”
“That I do,” replied Ctesippos laughing; “and I wish I could
administer the same discipline to you in your turn.”
“Then you beat your own father!”
“The beating,” answered the young man, “would be more justly inflicted
on yours, for having knowingly let loose two such sages upon
mankind!”[836]
Footnote 836:
Plat. Opp. t. iii. p. 245.—The amusing manner of teaching introduced
by these sophists was sometimes imitated by the philosophers. Thus
Theophrastus, who, before proceeding to his school, used to anoint
himself with oil and perform his exercises, had recourse to
extraordinary drollery for the purpose of charming his pupils,
adapting all his gestures and movements to his discourses; so that
when describing the manners and character of a glutton, he used,
like a comic actor, to thrust out his tongue and lick his
lips.—Athen. i. 38.
But these, after all, were but laughing sophists, who, though they had
succeeded in confounding and obliterating from their own minds every
trace of difference between right and wrong, fell short of that superb
degree of wickedness at which Polos, Callicles, and Thrasymachos
arrived, at least in speculation. The former were mere babblers, who
corrupted a pupil or two whom bad luck threw in their way.
Thrasymachos flew at higher game. His sophistry was political,[837]
and his aim the destruction of freedom, by extinguishing that sense of
justice on which it must ever be based. The genius of the man was
considerable. He had deep thoughts, and investigated boldly; but his
sympathies having somehow been early perverted, he grew sombre,
fierce, and unsociable, and without the slightest disguise advocated,
like our Hobbes,[838] tyrannical maxims and morals. Money, like the
rest, he of course worshipped. Nay, in the conversation at the house
of Cephalos he even ventures to sneer rudely at Socrates’ poverty;
upon which Glaucon[839] observes:—"Don’t fear to go unpaid for the
instruction you may give him, for we will enter into a subscription on
his behalf."[840] Thrasymachos, however, was still more vain than
avaricious. He thirsted to exhibit his notions in order to enjoy the
satisfaction arising from shocking those who heard him. He maintained
that justice is nothing more than what in any state the rulers think
proper to establish; and that, consequently, the ordinances of a
tyrant are as binding and as just as the laws of a free state, since
by nature all actions are indifferent.
Footnote 837:
Cf. Dem. Lacrit. § 10. Sch. Aristoph. Nub. 113.
Footnote 838:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account