Disregarding the physical circumstances, an intangible consideration
virtually compels the acceptance of this view. We have in the testimony
of all the eyewitnesses a substantial agreement on what took place.
Roden, Fournet, and Coleman saw the gun in Weiss’s hand and saw him fire
it. Frampton, Coleman, and Fournet saw and describe Long’s flight before
the crashing salvo by the other bodyguards began.
Their stories differ in detail. Frampton says Huey gave “a sort of a
grunt” when he was shot; Justice Fournet describes it as “a hoot.” He
also says the first shot was fired by Weiss, the next three by Coleman;
Roden says the first two shots were fired by Weiss, the third by
himself, and the fourth by someone else (obviously Coleman). Coleman
says Huey was attended by Roden, McQuiston, and himself on his final
visit to the House chamber, Fournet says he was accompanied by Messina,
and Frampton reports that Messina answered the telephone in the office
of the sergeant at arms, which opens off the Speaker’s rostrum and is
entirely separate from the House chamber.
These discrepancies are natural; only the absence of such variations
would lay the testimony of witnesses to a violent incident open to the
suspicion, nay the certainty, of collusion. Take for example the three
mutually contradictory versions of what happened when the two
principals, Roden and Weiss, locked in literally a life-and-death
grapple, fell struggling to the floor. Roden says his hard heels slipped
on the marble paving; Justice Fournet says he threw out his hands in a
gesture that overbalanced the two; Coleman says a blow of his fist
felled Weiss, who, clasped in Roden’s grip, pulled the latter down
beneath him.
But on the main point--namely, that the two fell to the floor, and that
Weiss was not killed until after they were down--all are in complete
agreement. If it is assumed that this is a concocted story, made up to
divert suspicion from one or more of the bodyguards as having fired so
wildly that one of their bullets brought about their leader’s death, the
following must likewise be accepted as true:
Somewhere and sometime before the first of these four witnesses told
what he saw, all of them would have had to agree on the specific
untruths they would tell.
But at no time was there any opportunity during those initial frantic
moments for the four to have met, either to concoct and agree on a false
story or for any other purpose. Indeed, Frampton was already telephoning
his first story of what had occurred, while the others are all accounted
for elsewhere: Coleman describing to Governor Allen what he had seen,
Justice Fournet in the hospital, Roden out of action and temporarily
blinded until taken to the hospital himself by Ty Campbell.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account