The remark has with justice been made by M. Hamy, that there
probably exist in India, in the midst of populations driven back
by the Aryan invasion, representatives of the Neanderthal type.
Nevertheless, to find them with any degree of certainty, we must go
as far as Australia. Our investigations have on this point confirmed
those of Huxley. Among the races of this great island there is
one, distributed particularly in the province of Victoria, in the
neighbourhood of Port Western, which reproduces in a remarkable
manner the characters of the Canstadt race.
Finally, the Canstadt race has had representatives in America also.
One of the drawings published by MM. Lacerta and Peixoto leaves no
room for doubt on this point. It represents almost the whole of
the upper part of a cranial vault found in the province of Ceara,
the resemblance of which with that of Eguisheim is very striking.
Unfortunately, the Brazilian naturalists say nothing about the
situation of this precious fragment at the moment of its discovery,
and we do not know whether the cranium in question is a fossil or
whether it belongs to the present epoch.
V. All these facts, which I have been obliged to sum up in a few
lines, raise an important problem, and lead to an interesting
conclusion.
Are we, in the first place, justified in connecting ethnologically
the crania of a more or less Neanderthal type, discovered in
the Antipodes as well as in Europe, with the races, the remains
of which have been preserved by the quaternary alluvium? Is not
the reproduction of this type purely accidental? Do not the most
ancient crania owe their remarkable characters to some pathological
condition, to a simple deviation from the normal development, and
particularly to a premature union of the bones of the cranium?
These several opinions have been maintained, and the latter in
particular has had adherents. It rests principally upon the condition
of the ossified sutures of the Neanderthal cranium. But these same
sutures may be observed in the Canstadt cranium. M. Sauvage found in
the almost infantine frontal bone of La Denise all the Neanderthal
characters, although the medio-frontal suture as yet only existed in
part. It is entirely open in the cranium of the young man, discovered
in a Poitou tumulus, described by M. Pruner Bey, and which it is
impossible not to connect with the preceding.
Thus we cannot attribute to the premature ossification of the
sutures, the form of the crania of the men of Canstadt. For a much
stronger reason, the clearly marked characters of the forehead and
face which remain cannot support this theory, and we must allow that
the whole constitutes a true ethnical type.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account