The observer on whose authority Lepeletier de Saint-Fargeau says a word
or two touching the habits of this same Sphex witnessed a similar
storing away of Locusts in Africa, near Oran. He surprised a
Yellow-winged Sphex dragging an Acridian along. Was it an accidental
case, like that which I witnessed on the banks of the Rhône? Was it an
exception or the rule? Can there be a lack of Crickets in the country
around Oran and does the Wasp fill their place with Acridians? The
force of circumstances compels me to put the question without finding a
reply.
This is the place to interpolate a certain passage from Lacordaire’s
[27] Introduction to Entomology against which I am eager to protest.
Here it is:
‘Darwin, [28] who wrote a book on purpose to prove the identity of
the intellectual principle actuating men and animals, was walking
one day in his garden when he saw on the path a Sphex who had just
possessed herself of a Fly almost as large as herself. He saw her
cut off the victim’s head and abdomen with her mandibles, keeping
only the thorax, to which the wings remained attached, after which
she flew away; but a breath of wind, striking the Fly’s wings, made
the Sphex spin round and prevented her progress; hereupon she
alighted again on the path, cut off one of the Fly’s wings and then
the other, and, after thus destroying the cause of her
difficulties, resumed her flight with what remained of her prey.
This fact carries with it manifest signs of reasoning power.
Instinct might have led this Sphex to cut off her victim’s wings
before carrying it to her nest, as do some species of the same
genus; but here there was a sequence of ideas and results from
those ideas, which are quite inexplicable unless we allow the
intervention of reason.’
This little story, which so lightly grants reason to an insect, lacks I
will not say truth, but even mere likelihood, not in the act itself,
which I accept without reserve, but in the motives for the act. Darwin
saw what he tells us; only, he was mistaken as to the heroine of the
drama, the drama itself and its significance. He was profoundly
mistaken; and I will prove it.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account