First of all, the old English scientist was bound to know enough about
the creatures to which he gives these high dignities to call things by
their right names. Let us therefore take the word Sphex in its strict
scientific meaning. Under this assumption, by what strange aberration
was this English Sphex, if any such there be, choosing a Fly for her
prey, when her kinswomen hunt such different game, Orthoptera? Even
admitting what I consider to be inadmissible, a Fly to form the quarry
of a Sphex, other difficulties come crowding up. It is now duly proved
that the Burrowing Wasps do not take dead bodies to their larvæ, but a
victim merely numbed, paralysed. Then what is the meaning of this prey
of which the Sphex cuts off the head, the abdomen, the wings? The stump
carried away is no more than a fragment of a corpse, which would infect
the cell with its rottenness, without being of any use to the larva,
whose hatching is not due for some days yet. It is as clear as
daylight: when making his observation, Darwin did not have before him a
Sphex in the strict sense of the word. Then what did he see?
The term Fly, by which the captured prey is designated, is a very
elastic word, which can be applied to the immense order of Diptera and
which therefore leaves us undecided among thousands of species. The
expression Sphex is most likely also employed in an equally indefinite
sense. At the end of the eighteenth century, when Darwin’s book
appeared, this expression was used to denote not only the Sphegidæ
proper, but particularly the Crabronidæ. Now, among the latter, some,
when storing provisions for their larvæ, hunt Diptera, Flies, the prey
required by the unknown Hymenopteron of the English naturalist. Then
was Darwin’s Sphex a Crabro? No; for these Dipteron-hunters, like the
hunters of any other prey, want game that keeps fresh, motionless but
half-alive, for the fortnight or three weeks required for the hatching
of the eggs and the complete development of the larvæ. All these little
ogres need meat killed that day and not gone bad or even a little high.
This is a rule to which I know of no exception. The word Sphex cannot
be accepted therefore, even with its old meaning.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account