The Indian operation of couching for cataractElliot, Robert Henry
History
The Indian operation of couching for cataract
Elliot, Robert Henry
Cataract -- Surgery -- India; Ophthalmology -- India -- History
=Pain.=--The pain which follows the operation of couching has attracted
the attention of surgeons from very early times, and there has been
much speculation as to its cause. When, after Daviel’s discovery,
extraction came into serious competition with the older operation,
surgeons discussed at much length the relative merit of the two
procedures, and it was strongly urged by the extractionists that their
operation gave rise to less pain than that of couching. The subject
is a very difficult one, for no surgeon, who has had a large cataract
practice, can fail to have been struck by the extraordinary difference
in the statements of patients as to the amount of suffering they have
endured during the first twenty-four hours after the removal of a lens.
The majority of them confess to a good deal of pain; this comes on as
the effect of the anæsthetic wears off, reaches a maximum, and then
slowly dies away, leaving them at the end of twelve hours, and often
even at the end of six hours, comparatively comfortable. Occasionally,
but rarely, the report is that the pain has been negligible throughout.
On the other hand, a bitter complaint of very severe pain is sometimes
encountered; fortunately such an occurrence is infrequent. In the case
sheets on which the writer’s 780 cases were taken, a special heading
was provided for notes on the pain inflicted at or after operation. A
striking feature of the replies given was the extraordinary difference
between them; this is the more astonishing because in a large number of
the operations it is probable that no anæsthetic of any kind was used,
and yet it was by no means uncommon to meet with patients, who made
little or nothing of the pain either at the operation or after it.
On the other hand, some complained of terrible suffering, commencing
as soon as the needle was inserted, and lasting for long periods
thereafter. The majority admitted to some pain, but neither belittled
nor exaggerated it. It will thus be seen that, so far as pain is
concerned, the experiences of the coucher and of the extractor are much
alike; it is unfair to judge either operation on exceptional cases.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account