The Indian operation of couching for cataractElliot, Robert Henry
History
The Indian operation of couching for cataract
Elliot, Robert Henry
Cataract -- Surgery -- India; Ophthalmology -- India -- History
=Reascension of Couched Cataract.=--This subject has been partly
dealt with in the preceding paragraphs. Naturally, it was a topic
which attracted a good deal of attention from the early writers, who
commented on its relative frequency immediately after the operation,
and gave elaborate instructions to prevent its occurrence. Some of them
went so far as to suggest the frequent repetition of the operation, if
necessary. In their experience it would appear that, if reascension
failed to occur within the first fortnight, the prospect of the lens
remaining down was good. Nevertheless, they were familiar with the fact
that, even after years of a happy result, the cataract might suddenly
be found to have returned to its old position opposite the pupil. In
some cases this misfortune followed a blow or fall on the head, or a
severe jar of the whole body. Similar stories may be heard in an Indian
out-patient room to-day. This is a point which must be taken well into
consideration by any who think fit to resort to couching in selected
cases.
=A Comparison of the Corneal and Scleral Routes for Operation.=--It has
been already shown that the Indian operators of the present day vary
in their technique, some attacking the lens from in front through the
cornea, and others from behind through the sclera. It is interesting
to note that there is a similar difference in practice amongst those of
the modern surgeons who have adopted couching in special cases. There
can, however, be no doubt that the weight of opinion among the old
writers was all in favour of the posterior operation; and Mackenzie,
whose practical experience was, we may hope, vastly greater than that
of any modern surgeon, summed up the position in these words: “In
this way (_i.e._, through the cornea) neither operation (depression
or reclination) can be satisfactorily performed.” We may close this
subject with another word of warning to any who are inclined to favour
the couching of lenses in selected cases. From the time of Celsus
onwards, surgeons who have had large experience in couching have warned
their disciples that it is an operation much more easy to undertake
than to carry to a successful technical issue, and have cautioned them
against venturing on it until they have seen it performed many times at
the hands of an expert. One cannot conclude better than by a quotation
from the writings of Lieut.-Colonel Henry Smith, who has had very large
opportunities of observing the results of cataract couching. He is
known to be a very skilful operator, and one, therefore, who is little
likely to exaggerate the difficulties of any ophthalmic procedure, yet
he writes: “It is no easy matter to completely dislocate the lens, and,
in my observation, the partial dislocation is more frequent than the
complete in the hands of adepts of the art.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account