The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial artsVeblen, Thorstein
Philosophy
The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial arts
Veblen, Thorstein
Industrial arts -- History; Industries -- History; Technology -- History; Workmanship -- History
Under the simpler technology of more primitive industrial systems
recourse to anthropomorphic imputation has also always been a hindrance
to workmanlike mastery, more particularly in the mechanic arts proper,
and only less pronounced in those industrial arts, like husbandry,
that have to do immediately with plants and animals. Knowledge of
brute facts as interpreted in terms of human nature appears never to
have been serviceable in full proportion to their content. But in
these more primitive industrial systems--as also in the better days
of handicraft--the workman is forever in instant control of his tools
and materials; the movements made use of in the work are essentially
of the nature of manipulation, in which the workman adroitly coerces
the materials into shapes and relations that will answer his purpose,
and in which also nothing (typically) takes place beyond the manual
reach of the workman as extended by the tools which his hands make use
of. Under these conditions it is a matter of relatively slight effect
whether the workman does or does not rate the objects which he uses as
tools and materials in quasi-personal terms or imputes to them a degree
of self-direction, since they are at no point allowed to escape his
manual reach and are by direct communication of his force, dexterity
and judgment coerced into the forms, motions and spatial dispositions
aimed at by him. His imputing some bias, bent, initiative or spiritual
force or infirmity to brute matter will doubtless incapacitate him by
so much for efficiently designing processes and uses for the available
material facts; his creative imagination proceeds on mistaken premises
and goes wrong in so far; and so this anthropomorphic interpretation
must always count as a material drawback to technological mastery
of the available resources and in some degree retard the possible
advance in the industrial arts. But within the premises given by the
industrial arts as they stand, he may still do effective work as a
mechanic skilled in the manual operations prescribed by the given state
of the arts. For in the mechanic industries of all these other and
more archaic industrial systems the workman does the work; it may be
by use of tools, and even by help of more or less extended processes
in which natural forces of growth, fermentation, decay, and the like,
play a material part; but the decisive fact remains that the motions
and operations of such manual industry take effect at his hands and by
way of his muscular force and manual reach. Where natural processes, as
those of growth, fermentation or combustion, are drawn into the routine
of industry, they lie, as natural processes, beyond his discretionary
control; at the most he puts them in train and lets them run, with some
hedging and shifting as they go on, to bring them to bear in such a way
as shall suit his ends; he takes his precautions with them and then he
takes the chance of their coming to the desired issue. They are not,
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account