The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial artsVeblen, Thorstein
Philosophy
The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial arts
Veblen, Thorstein
Industrial arts -- History; Industries -- History; Technology -- History; Workmanship -- History
On this head, as regards the requirements of industry in the way of
general information on the part of the skilled workmen, the contrast
is sufficiently marked, _e. g._, between Elizabethan times and the
Victorian age. At the earlier period illiteracy was no obstacle to
adequate training in the skilled trades. In the seventeenth century
Thomas Mun includes among the peculiar and extraordinary acquirements
necessary to eminent success in commerce, matters that are now easily
comprised in the ordinary common-school instruction; and in so doing
he plainly shows that these acquirements were over and above what was
usual or would be thought useful for the common man. Even Adam Smith,
in the latter half of the eighteenth century, shrewd observer as he
was, does not include any degree of schooling or any similar pursuit of
general information among the requisites essential to the efficiency of
skilled labour. Even at that date it appears still to have been true
that the commonplace information and the general training necessary to
a mastery of any one of the crafts lay within so narrow a range that
what was needful could all be acquired by hearsay and as an incident
to the discipline of apprenticeship. Within a century after the first
inception of the machine industry illiteracy had come to be a serious
handicap to any skilled mechanic; the range of commonplace information
that must habitually be drawn on in the skilled trades had widened to
such an extent, and comprised so large a volume of recondite facts,
that the ability to read came to have an industrial value; the
higher proficiency in any branch of the mechanic arts presumed such
an acquaintance with fact and theory as could neither be gained nor
maintained without habitual recourse to printed matter. And this line
of requirements has been constantly increasing in volume and urgency,
as well as in the range of employments to which the demand applies,
until it has become a commonplace that no one can now hope to compete
for proficiency in the skilled occupations without such schooling as
will carry him very appreciably beyond the three R’s that made up the
complement of necessary learning for the common man half a century ago.
It follows as a consequence of these large and increasing requirements
enforced by the machine technology that the period of preliminary
training is necessarily longer, and the schooling demanded for general
preparation grows unremittingly more exacting. So that, apart from all
question of humanitarian sentiment or of popular fitness for democratic
citizenship, it has become a matter of economic expediency, simply as
a proposition in technological efficiency at large, to enforce the
exemption of children from industrial employment until a later date
and to extend their effective school age appreciably beyond what would
once have been sufficient to meet all the commonplace requirements of
skilled workmanship.[140]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account