The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial artsVeblen, Thorstein
Philosophy
The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial arts
Veblen, Thorstein
Industrial arts -- History; Industries -- History; Technology -- History; Workmanship -- History
Child labour, which once may, industrially speaking, have been an
economical method of consuming the available human material, is no
longer compatible with the highest industrial efficiency, even apart
from any question of hardship or deterioration incident to an excessive
or abusive recourse to child labour; it is incompatible with the
community’s material interests. Therefore the business community--the
body of businessmen at large--for whose behoof the industries of the
country are carried on, have a direct interest not only in extending
the age of exemption from industrial employment but also in procuring
an adequate schooling of the incoming generation of workmen. The
business community is evidently coming to appreciate this state of the
case, at least in some degree, as is evidenced by their inclination to
favour instruction in the “practical” branches in the public schools,
at the public expense, as well as by the wide-reaching movement that
aims to equip private and state schools that shall prepare the youth
for work in the various lines of industrial employment.
[141] _Cf._, _e. g._, Adam Smith’s reflections on the uses of an
accurate watch, _Theory of the Moral Sentiments_, part iv, ch. 2.
[142] On the other hand the aphorism often cited, that “Necessity
is the Mother of Invention,” appears to be nothing better than a
fragment of uncritical rationalism. It offers a rationalised, _ex
post facto_ account of changes that take place, and reflects that
ancient preconception by help of which the spokesmen of edification
were enabled to interpret all change as an improvement due to the
achievement of some definitely foreknown end. It appears also to be
consistently untrue, except so far as “invention” is to be taken as a
euphemistic synonym for “prevarication.” Doubtless, the felt need of
ways and means has brought on many changes in technology, but doubtless
also the ulterior consequences of any one of the greater mechanical
inventions have in the main been neither foreseen nor intended in the
designing of them. The more serious consequences, especially such as
have an institutional bearing, have been enforced by the inventions
rather than designed by the inventors.
[143] See pp. 18–21, above.
[144] Cf., however, what has been said above (pp. 21–23) of the
variability and adaptability of a hybrid population and the possible
selective establishment of a hybrid type more suitable to current
conditions of life than any one of the racial stocks out of which the
hybrid population is made up.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account