The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial artsVeblen, Thorstein
Philosophy
The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial arts
Veblen, Thorstein
Industrial arts -- History; Industries -- History; Technology -- History; Workmanship -- History
By this indirect, animistic and magical, line of approach the
matter-of-fact requirements of tillage and cattle-breeding can be
determined and fulfilled in a very passable fashion, given only the
necessary time and tranquillity. Time is by common consent allowed the
stone-age culture in abundant measure; and common consent is coming,
through one consideration and another, to admit that the requisite
conditions of peace and quiet industry are also a characteristic
feature of that early time. The fact, broad and profound, that the
known crop plants and animals were for the most part domesticated in
that time is perhaps in itself the most persuasive argument for the
prevalence of peaceful conditions among those peoples, whoever they
may have been, to whose efforts, or rather to whose routine of genial
superstition, this domestication is to be credited. This domestication
and use of plants and animals was of course not a mere blindfold
diversion. Here as ever the instinct of workmanship was present
with its prompting to make the most of what comes to hand; and the
technology of husbandry, like the technology of any other industrial
enterprise, has been the outcome of men’s abiding penchant for making
things useful.
The peculiar advantage of tillage and cattle-breeding over the primary
mechanic arts, that by which the former arts gained and kept their
lead, seems to have been the simple circumstance that the propensity
of workmanlike men to impute a workmanlike (teleological) nature to
phenomena does not leave the resulting knowledge of these phenomena
so wide of the mark in the case of animate nature as in that of brute
matter. It will probably not do to say that the anthropomorphic
imputation has been directly serviceable to the technological end
in the case of tillage and cattle-breeding; it is rather that the
disadvantage or disserviceability of such an interpretation of facts
has been greater in the mechanic arts in early times. The instinct of
workmanship, through the sentimental propensity to impute workmanlike
qualities and conduct to external facts, has defeated itself more
effectually in the mechanic arts. And as in the course of time, under
favourable local conditions, the habitual imputation of teleological
capacities has in some measure fallen into disuse, the mechanic arts
have gained; and every such gain has in its turn, as conditions
permitted, acted cumulatively toward the discredit and disuse of the
teleological method of knowledge, and therefore toward an acceleration
of technological gain in this field.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account