The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial artsVeblen, Thorstein
Philosophy
The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial arts
Veblen, Thorstein
Industrial arts -- History; Industries -- History; Technology -- History; Workmanship -- History
It is otherwise with the bearing of the parental bent on the arts of
tillage and cattle-breeding. Here its promptings are almost wholly
serviceable to technological gain as well as to assiduous workmanship.
The kindly sentiments intrinsic to the parental bent are admirably in
place in the care of plants and animals, and their good effects in
so giving a propitious turn to the technology of early tillage and
cattle-breeding are only re-enforced by the parental and workmanlike
inclination to husband resources and make the most of what comes to
hand. The particular turn given to the anthropomorphic bias by this
line of preconceptions also is rather favourable than otherwise to
a working insight into the requirements of the art. And it has had
certain specific consequences for the early technology of husbandry, as
well as for the early culture in which husbandry was the chief material
factor, such as to call for a more circumstantial account.
Under the canons of workmanship a teleological animus--an instinctive
or “spiritual” nature--is imputed to the plants and animals brought
into domestication. The art of husbandry proceeds on the apprehended
needs and proclivities so imputed, and the technology of the craft
therefore takes the form of a “tendance” designed to further these
quasi-animistically conceived beings in whatever ends they have at
heart by virtue of their natural bent, and to so direct this tendance
upon them as will conduce to shaping their scheme of life in ways
advantageous to man. Like other sentient beings, as is known to
shrewd and unsophisticated man, they have spiritual needs as well
as material needs, and they are putatively to be influenced by the
attitude of their human cousins towards them and their conduct,
interests, and adventures. Further, their life and comfort are
manifestly conditioned by the run of the seasons and of the weather;
various inclemencies are discouraging and discomforting to them, as to
mankind, and other vicissitudes of rain and shine and tempest are of
the gravest consequence to them for good or ill. Under these delicate
circumstances it is incumbent on the keepers of crops and flocks to
walk circumspectly and cultivate the good-will not only of their crops
and flocks but also of the natural phenomena that count for so much in
the life of the crops and flocks. These natural phenomena are of course
also conceived anthropomorphically, in the sense that they too are seen
to follow their natural bent and do what they will,--or perhaps more
commonly what the personal agents will, in whose keeping these natural
phenomena are conceived to lie; for unsophisticated man has no other
available terms in which to conceive them and their behaviour than the
terms of initiative, design and endeavour immediately given in his own
conscious action.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account