The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial artsVeblen, Thorstein
Philosophy
The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial arts
Veblen, Thorstein
Industrial arts -- History; Industries -- History; Technology -- History; Workmanship -- History
Now, when any given technological or decorative element crosses the
frontier between one culture and another, in the course of borrowing,
it is likely to happen that it will come into the new culture stripped
of most or all of its anthropomorphic or spiritual virtues and
limitations, more particularly, of course, if the cultural frontier in
question is at the same time a linguistic frontier; since the borrowing
is likely to be made from motives of workmanlike expediency, and the
putative spiritual attributes of the facts involved are not obvious
to men who have not been trained to impute them. The chief exception
to such a rule would be any borrowing that takes effect on religious
grounds, in which case, of course, the magical or symbolic efficacy
of the borrowed elements are the substance that is sought in the
borrowing. Herein, presumably, lies much of the distinctive character
of the north-European prehistoric culture, which was in an eminent
degree built up out of borrowed elements, so far as concerns both its
technology and its art. And to this free and voluminous borrowing may
likewise be due the apparent poverty of this early culture in religious
or magical elements.
A further effect follows. The borrowing being (relatively) unencumbered
with ritual restrictions and magical exactions attached to their
employment, they would fall into the scheme of things as mere
matter-of-fact, to be handled with the same freedom and unhindered
sagacity with which a workman makes use of his own hands, and could,
without reservation, be turned to any use for which they were
mechanically suited. Something of symbolism and superstition might,
of course, be carried over in the borrowing, and something more would
unavoidably be bred into the borrowed elements in the course of their
use; but the free start would always count for something in the
outcome, both as regards the rate of progress made in the exploitation
of the expedients acquired by borrowing and in the character of the
technological system at large into which they had been introduced.
Both the relative freedom from magical restraint and the growth of
home-made anthropomorphic imputations may easily be detected in the
course of this northern culture and in its outcome in modern times.
Cattle, for instance, are a borrowed technological fact in the Baltic
and North-Sea region, but superstitious practices seem never to have
attached to cattle-breeding in that region in such volume and rigorous
exaction as may be found nearer the original home of the domesticated
species; and yet the volume of folk-lore, mostly of a genial and
relatively unobstructive character, that has in later times grown up
about the care of cattle in the Scandinavian countries is by no means
inconsiderable.
CHAPTER IV
THE TECHNOLOGY OF THE PREDATORY CULTURE
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account