The International Monthly, Volume 5, No. 4, April, 1852Various
History
The International Monthly, Volume 5, No. 4, April, 1852
Various
Art, Modern -- 19th century -- Periodicals; Literature, Modern -- 19th century -- Periodicals; Science -- History -- Periodicals
The London _Morning Chronicle_ furnishes a biography of Moore, which we
slightly abridge. With him, says the _Chronicle_, is snapped the last
tie, save perhaps one, represented by the veteran Rogers, which connects
the present generation with the outburst of "all the talents" which
signalized the opening of the century. That great kindling of
genius--embracing almost all sides of imaginative literature, of
criticism and philosophy--is becoming more a thing of history than of
fact. Year by year, the lights are going out. Wordsworth was the last
extinguished before Moore; and now, to all intents and purposes, the
great galaxy which poured such a flood of light on the literature of
fifty years ago--which extinguished Rosa Matilda fiction and Delia
Cruscan poetry--substituted true criticism for technical carping upon
philological points, and established new styles in every branch of the
_belles-lettres_--this great constellation may now be said to have
disappeared. One of the brightest, if not of the largest stars, has long
been obscured, and is now quite put out. The fame of Moore is fairly a
matter of discussion. It cannot, we believe, be denied that much of his
serious and more ambitious verse, founded on promptings of a more
luscious and florid fancy than the present tastes incline to admit, and
no inconsiderable portion even of his lyric pieces,--refined to
attenuation--are less read and admired than they were a score or thirty
years ago. A severer and sterner school of poetry has succeeded--one of
deeper feeling and more sober thought; and the representatives of those
who revelled in _Lalla Rookh_, and delighted in the strains of Mr.
Little, now generally address themselves to more staid and philosophic
musings. The _Irish Melodies_, too--exquisite as is their
word-music--fanciful as is their conception--delightful as is their
playfulness, and touching as is their pathos--even the _Irish Melodies_,
we believe are declining in popular estimation. The reasons are obvious.
In the first place, the _Irish Melodies_ are not particularly Irish;
they have grace, sparkling fancy, delicious feeling; but they are too
fine-spun to do the work-a-day duty of popular songs. As literary
performances, nine-tenths of Burns's are inferior to Moore's; and all
Dibdin's are immeasurably beneath them. Yet the probability is that
_When Willie Brewed_, and _Poor Tom Bowling_, will be in the full tide
of popularity, where _Rich and Rare_, and _Oh Breathe not His Name_,
will be unsung and forgotten. In a certain circle, and among people of a
certain reading and appreciation, Moore will live as long as the
language; but his genius was delicate and acute rather than catholic and
strong. He had a rich play of fancy, but none of the soaring imagination
of Shelley or Byron. His mind, in fact, was a first-class second-rate.
It had no pretensions to stand in the line of the giants of his time.
Brightly fanciful, rather than continuously imaginative--teeming with
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account