The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth TheoryRobertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Religion
The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth Theory
Robertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Jesus Christ
Nevertheless, polytheism is just as surely popular as monotheism
is inevitable to the more thoughtful who remain "religious" in the
natural sense of the term. One of the great delusions maintained by the
acceptance of the falsified history of Judaism and the conventional
religion of the Bible is the notion that the Jews were a specially
monotheistic people. They were not. [325] They were originally
tribalists like their neighbours, holding by a tribal God and a
hierarchy of inferior Gods. To this day we are seriously told that
Abraham made a new departure as a monotheist. Abraham is a mythical
patriarch, himself once a deity; and the deity represented to have been
believed in by Abraham is a tribal God. And not even the tribal God
was monotheistically worshipped. The Sacred Books are one long chain
of complaints against the Israelites for their perpetual resort to
"strange Gods"--and Goddesses. [326]
Two brilliant French scholars have advanced the thesis that this
alleged polytheism is imaginary; [327] and that the Israelites in
the mass always worshipped only the One God Yahweh. [328] But this
position, which is grounded on the inference that the mass of the
historical and prophetic literature is post-exilic, outgoes its own
grounds. Even if we assume, with the theorists, that Jewish monotheism
was universalist from the moment it took shape as monotheism in
literature, [329] we get rid neither of the question of pre-exilic
polytheism nor of that of popular survival. To say that the post-exilic
Jews are "the only Jews known to history," and that the apparently old
lore in Genesis is "perhaps really the most modern," being invented
for purposes of parable, is only a screening of the fact that the
Hebrews evolved religiously like other peoples. A resort to alien
Gods is seen to be universal in the religious history of the ancient
world. Every conquered race was suspected to have secret power in
respect of "the God of the land [330]"; and wherever races mixed,
cults mixed. It is only on a provision of special Sacred Books,
themselves treated as fetishes, that the attractions of alien cults
can be repelled; and not even Sacred Books can make real monotheists
of an uncultured majority. Even later Judaism, with its angels, its
Metatron, its Satan, was never truly monotheistic. [331] Islam is
not. The universalism which in later Judaism still commonly passes
for a specialty of the Hebrew mind was really an assimilation and
development of Perso-Babylonian ideas; [332] and Satan made a dualism
of the Jewish creed even as Ahriman did of the Persian.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account