The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth TheoryRobertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Religion
The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth Theory
Robertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Jesus Christ
The Christists, then, when they began to form groups, were doing what
a swarm of other movements did. Their ecclesiæ were called by a pagan
name, as were the Jewish synagogues. Two things it behoved them to do
if they were collectively to gain ground and outlive or out-top the
rest: they must multiply in membership, and they must co-ordinate their
groups; and both things they did on lines of common action. Membership
was from the first promoted by the simplest of all methods, systematic
almsgiving to poor adherents; a practice long before initiated by the
Jewish synagogues and to this day fixed among them. Given the basis
of free association, the inculcated duty of almsgiving, the eastern
belief in its saving virtue, [351] and the special Christian belief
in the speedy end of the world, the problem of membership was early
solved. The poor, helped one day, would themselves help the next,
as is their human way in all ages; and in an age of general poverty,
the result of an autocratic fiscal system in the Empire as afterwards
in the Turkish Empire which in the East took its place, such mutual
sympathy constituted a broad social basis of corporate existence.
For our ecclesiastical historian, the poverty is the main determinant
on the side of early organization. With a note of profound pessimism,
which alternates strangely with passages of professional eulogy of the
Church, he notes that pauperism and philanthropy were going hand in
hand already throughout the Empire before the advent of Christianity,
rich men and municipalities proclaiming an "almost Christian sentiment"
on the subject. "The instinct of benevolence was fairly roused. And
yet to the mass of men life was hardly worth living. It tended to
become a despair." [352] And he claims that the Christian practice
of almsgiving--which he knows to have been warmly inculcated among
the Jews, as it has always been in Eastern countries--was one of the
conservative forces that "arrested decay. They have prevented the
disintegration, and possibly the disintegration by a vast and ruinous
convulsion, of the social fabric. Of those forces the primitive bishops
and deacons were the channels and the ministers.... They bridged over
the widening interval between class and class. They lessened to the
individual soul the weight of that awful sadness of which, then as now,
to the mass of men, life was the synonym and the sum." [353]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account