The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth TheoryRobertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Religion
The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth Theory
Robertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Jesus Christ
And I can "see no prospect" of a long currency for Professor
Schmiedel's panegyric of fictitious sayings in Acts [468] as "of the
deepest that can be said about the inner Christian life." If that
be so, what amount of profundity goes to the whole construction
of the faith? How long is it to be maintained that the secret or
inspiration of good life lies in the ideas of men for whom the framing
of false history was a pious occupation? The main ethical content
of the Christian system, the moral doctrine by which the Church
has lived down till the other day, is the ethic-defying doctrine
of the redemption of mankind by a blood sacrifice--a survival of
immemorial savagery. That is still the specifically "evangelical"
view of Christianity. After living by the doctrine through two eras,
the slowly civilizing conscience of the Church has itself begun
to repudiate it; and we have the characteristic spectacle of its
defenders declaring that the very terms of the historic creed form a
libel framed by its enemies. Taught at last by human reason that the
doctrine of sacrifice is the negation of morality, they pretend that
that doctrine is not Christian. Without it, their Church would never
have taken its historic form. To eliminate it, they have to suppress
half their literature, prose and verse. The accommodations by which
the fundamental immorality has been modified in the interests of
saner morality are but the dictates of human experience; and these
dictates are in turn pretended to be the revelation of the faith that
flouted them.
Unless the world is again to retrogress collectively in its
civilization, this polemic will not long avail to obscure historic
issues. It is not merely the "religion" of Professor Drews, it is
the emancipated human reason, that denies the mortmain of ancient
Syria over the field of ethical thought, and claims the birthright
of modern man in his own moral law. Not one day has passed since the
penning of the Apocalypse without men's hating each other in the name
of Jesus. Wars generations long have been waged for interpretations
of the lore. Hatred and malice and all uncharitableness stamp all
the Sacred Books; and the literature of the Fathers imports into the
dwindling intellectual life of the West all the rancour of battling
Judaism. In our own day, Professor Schmiedel is malignantly assailed
in the name of the divinity of the figure of which he claims to
prove the exemplary humanity, his reasoned argument winning him
no goodwill from the supernaturalists. And around him there figure
virulent partisans, incapable of his candour, so little capable of
love for enemies that they cannot conduct a debate without passion,
perversion and insolence. A multitude of those who acclaim the gospel
Jesus as the supreme Teacher reveal themselves as below the standards
of normal candour.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account