The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth TheoryRobertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Religion
The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth Theory
Robertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Jesus Christ
[473] A pagan as well as a Jewish commonplace. Cp. Jeremiah xxi,
8; Hesiod, Works and Days, 285 sq.; Xenophon, Memorabilia, ii, 1;
Persius, Sat. iii, 56. Persius followed Pythagoras, who taught that
the ways of virtue and vice were like the thin and thick lines of the
letter Y. This is the origin of the Christian formula of the broad
and the narrow path. The conception of "the right way" is found among
the ancient Persians. Meyer, Geschichte des Alterthums, i, 539 (§ 448).
[474] Cp. Levit. xix, 18; Matt. xxii, 37-39.
[475] Cp. Tobit iv, 15; Matt. vii, 12. Hillel (Talmud, Sabbath, 306)
puts the rule, as here, in the sane negative form, which is also the
Chinese. The gospel form is less rational. The sentiment is the first
principle of morals, and is common to all religions and all races.
[476] Cp. Matt. v, 44; Prov. xxv, 21; Talmud refs. in C.M. 406;
and Test. of Twelve Patr. Dan. iii, iv; Gad, iii-vi. Canon Spence
notes that the resemblance between the Testaments and the Didachê is
"very marked." Note that in the Revised Version the text in Matthew
is cut down--a recognition of tampering, in imitation of Luke vi, 27-8.
[477] Gr. "the nations" = "the Gentiles." Here, as elsewhere, we render
by an English idiom, which gives the real force of the original. It
will be observed that the compilers of the first gospel (v, 46)
substitute "tax-gatherers" for the original, by way of applying the
discourse to Jews in Palestine, where the tax-gatherers represented
foreign oppression.
[478] A probable interpolation.
[479] Cp. Lament. iii, 30, and the pagan parallels cited by Mr. McCabe,
Sources of Mor. of Gospels, pp. 229, 231.
[480] This clause, which is not in Matthew, is intelligible only as
an exhortation to Jews in foreign lands. The reference to 1 Cor. vi,
1, cannot make it plausible as a Christian utterance.
[481] This is otherwise translated by the Rev. Mr. Heron, Church of
the Sub-Apostolic Age, p. 16, thus: "the Father wisheth men to give to
all from their private portion"; and by Dr. Taylor, Teaching, 1886,
p. 122, thus: "the Father wills that to all men there be given of
our own free gifts."
[482] Cp. Acts xx, 35. That passage probably derives from this,
and loses point in the transference.
[483] Mr. Heron renders this "under discipline," because the early
Church had no prison for its backsliders. Quite so. The reference is to
Pagan prisons, and the warning is to Jewish beggars. The Greek phrase,
en synochê, here clearly refers to a prison, though in Luke xxi, 25,
it is rendered "distress" and in 2 Cor. ii, 4, "anguish." Cp. Josephus,
8 Ant. iii, 2. Canon Spence, who translates "being in sore straits,"
offers the alternative "coming under arrest."
[484] Cp. Ecclesiasticus, xii, 1 sq. It will be observed that the
concluding clause modifies the earlier precept of indiscriminate
giving. It may be an addition.
[485] A more developed teaching is found in the Testaments of the
Patriarchs, as above cited.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account