The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth TheoryRobertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Religion
The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth Theory
Robertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Jesus Christ
[506] That is, Friday, called "the preparation" (for the Sabbath) by
the Jews. Mr. Heron notes that the Christians fasted on Wednesdays
and Fridays, but does not explain how a Christian document came to
use the Jewish expression with no Christian qualification.
[507] After all the previous allusions to "the Lord" (without the
article, save once in ch. iv and once in ch. vi) had plainly signified
"God," we here have "the Lord" (with the article) suddenly used in a
clearly Christian sense, to signify Jesus. The transition is flagrant.
[508] That is, in the original sense, thank-offering, as Mr. Gordon
notes. Now, the sacrament, as instituted in the gospels, is not
a thank-offering. It is evidently from the Didachê, or similar
early lore, that the word comes to be used for the sacrament by the
Fathers. It is never so used in the New Testament.
[509] As the American editors note, Clement of Alexandria (Quis
Dives Salvetur, § 29) calls Jesus "the vine of David." As Jesus is
"the vine" in the fourth gospel, but not in the synoptics, we may
surmise that the Didachê was current at Alexandria.
[510] Gr. paidos. Canon Spence and Mr. Heron render "Son"; but this
is not the normal word for son (huios), and the same term is used
for David and Jesus. It is rendered "servant" in Acts iii, 13, 26;
iv, 27, R.V.
[511] Gr. "in the ages."
[512] Cp. Matt. vii, 6. There is no such application there.
[513] Mr. Heron takes this to signify that the love-feast accompanied
the Eucharist. But he notes, from Dr. Taylor, that the Jews had
their chagigah before the Passover, in order that the latter might
be eaten "after being filled." Mr. Gordon translates: "After the
full reception."
[514] Gr. despota. The American editors (who render it "Master")
note that this word becomes rare in Christian literature towards the
latter part of the second century.
[515] So in the MS. Bryennios conjectures huiô (Son) for theô, but
this does not justify the alteration of the text by several editors.
[516] A Syriac phrase meaning not, as is sometimes said, "The Lord
cometh," but "The Lord is come." It was presumably an ancient formula
in the prayers hailing the rise of the sun.
[517] It is difficult to reconcile this arrangement with any of the New
Testament data as to the practice of the Jesuist apostles. Cp. Canon
Spence, p. 91, as to "the Jewish habit of wandering from place
to place."
[518] Cp. Mk. iii, 28-30; Matt. xii, 31; 1 Thess. v, 19, 20.
[519] The American editors have "a meal"; Canon Spence "a
Love-Feast." See his note. And cp. Jevons, Introd. to Hist. of
Religion, p. 333, as to the Greek agyrtes.
[520] On this obscure passage Mr. Heron has a long note, which,
however, supplies little light. Dr. Taylor notes that a "cosmic
mystery" [Gr. mystêrion kosmikon] is "the manifestation in the
phenomenal world of a 'mystery of the upper world,'" citing the
Zohar. Canon Spence suggests that the "table" connects with the
"mystery."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account