The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth TheoryRobertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Religion
The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth Theory
Robertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Jesus Christ
Even if we assume the earlier Jewish cult of Tammuz to have been swept
away in the Captivity, the new conditions would tend to stimulate
similar popular cults. When, after the Exile, the conception of Yahweh
began under Perso-Babylonian influences to alter in the direction
of a universalist theism, the common tendency to seek a nearer God
was bound to come into play. There is no more universal feature in
religious history than the recession of the High Gods. [181] The more
"supreme" a deity becomes, in popular religion, the more generally
does popular devotion tend to elicit Son-Gods or Goddesses who seem
more likely to be "hearers and answerers of prayer." Sacred Books
certainly tend to check such a reversion; and in Islam the check has
been successful in virtue of the very fact that Allah, like the early
Yahweh, is in effect conceived as a racial God, or God of a single
cult. But the tendency is seen at work all over the earth.
The vogue of Apollo, of Dionysos, of Herakles, of Tammuz-Adonis,
of Krishna, of Buddha, of Balder, of Athênê, of the Virgin Mary,
of the countless deities propitiated by savage peoples who ignore
their Supreme Gods, are all testimonies to the natural craving
of religious ignorance for a near God. The same craving certainly
subsisted among the Hebrews in so far as it was not completely laid
by organized legalism. And seeing that the redactors of the Sacred
Books had actually reduced many early deities--Abraham, Jacob,
Joseph, Daoud = David, Moses, Joshua, and Samson--to the status
of patriarchs and heroes, [182] the craving would among some be
relatively strengthened. Jews who in time of trouble chronically
reverted to alien Gods and alien rites, even as did the Greeks and
Romans, could not conceivably fail altogether to adopt or cherish
cults analogous to those of Dionysos, Adonis, Osiris, so popular
among the neighbouring peoples.
The hypothesis forced upon us by the whole history, then, is that
there had subsisted in Jewry, in original connection with a sacrificial
rite of Jesus the Son of the Father, a Sacrament of a Hero-God Jesus,
whose Name was strong to save. If it took the form of a Sacrament of
Twelve, with the ritual-representative of the God, it would be closely
analogous to the traditional Sacrament of Twelve in which Aaron [the
Anointed One = Messiah] and the [twelve] elders of Israel "ate bread
with Moses' father-in-law before God." [183] Behind that narrative
lies a ritual practice. A sacrament of bread and wine is further
indicated in the mention of the mythic Melchisedek, "King of Peace"
and priest of "El Elyon," [184] "without father and without mother,
without genealogy, having neither beginning of days or end of life,
but made like unto the Son of God," who thus became for Christists
a type of Jesus. [185] A sacramental banquet of twelve seems to have
been involved in the sacrificial ritual of the Temple itself, where
a presiding priest and twelve others daily officiated. [186]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account