The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth TheoryRobertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Religion
The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth Theory
Robertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Jesus Christ
"The identification of Christ with Joshua," remarks the orthodox
translator cited, "is a mixture of Jewish and Christian legend
(sic) which is unique. It is no question of symbolism here, as
Joshua in Christian writings is treated as a type of Christ, but
rather the confusion is such as might be made by an ignorant person
reading, Heb. iv, 8, 'if Jesus had given them rest,' and concluding
that Jesus Christ led the Jews into Canaan. The author, indeed,
identifies himself with the Jews, as where he prays (vers. 327 ff.):
'Spare Judea, Almighty Father, that we may see thy judgments'; and
were it credible that the whole book was the work of one author, we
should regard his religion as syncretic, and in full accord neither
with law nor gospel. But the book ... is of composite character. One
writer may have been a Christian; another filches occasionally from
Christian sources, but has no lively faith in Christ: like many of
his countrymen at this time, he suspends his judgment, and instead of
making a decision expends his energies in denunciation of the hated
power of Rome, and in speculations concerning the future."
It matters not whether the writer was or was not a confident
Christian: Judaic by upbringing or tuition he certainly was; and
his identification of Jesus the Christ with Joshua is one more of
the proofs that for many Jews Joshua had a quasi-divine status,
as was fitting for a personage who "made the sun stand still." Taken
collectively, the proofs cannot be overridden or explained away. Joshua
was for the Jews of the Hellenistic period the actual founder of
the rite of circumcision: [216] that is to say, mythologically,
he was the God of the rite. But still more weighty is the evidence
that his name lived on as that of the God-victim of a kindred rite;
and it is on that basis that there was founded the rite which is for
Christianity what circumcision had been for Judaism. Circumcision is
a rite of redemption, the giving of a symbolic part of the body to
"redeem" the whole--a surrogate for the Passover sacrifice of the
first-born, developed into a racial theocratic rite. It is significant
that the Saviour-God of this rite becomes the Saviour-God of the
rite offered in place of that of the Passover, whereby the primordial
human sacrifice is re-typified in that of the deity who once for all
dies for all. It is upon such roots of pre-historic religion that
the world-religions grow.
§ 3. The Mystery-Drama
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account