The belief in the coming of Messiah in some future time has been, like
the belief in the Unity of God, the source of vexatious disputations
between Jews and non-Jews. Mohammedans and Christians tried by all
means in their power to convince the Jews that the Anointed whose
advent was prophesied by the Prophets had already appeared, the former
pointing to Mohammed, the latter to Jesus, as the person realising
those predictions. The Biblical passages adduced as evidence prove
nothing of the kind. E.g., the three names, Sinai, Seir, and Paran, in
Deut. xxxiii. 2, were interpreted by Mohammedans to refer to three
revelations through Moses, Jesus, and Mohammed; and Mohammed being
mentioned last, his revelation was to be the final one. It is not
necessary to contradict such reasoning; one need only read the text in
order to see the absurdity of the argument. Christians quoted passages
from Isaiah which had no reference whatever to Messiah in evidence of
the Messianity of Jesus. Children born in the days of Isaiah (vii. 14;
viii. 18), whose names had reference to good or evil events of the
time, were wrongly interpreted as referring to the birth of Jesus; the
sufferings and final relief of the servant of the Lord, that is, Israel
(chaps. lii. and liii.), were applied to Jesus; the Psalmist who sings
of victories which God will grant to David (cx.) is made to declare the
divinity of Jesus.
Commentators and philosophers have taken notice of these arguments and
refuted them. Of the many works on these topics a few may be named:
“Nitsachon” (נצחון), by Lipmann Mühlhausen (1400), “Strengthening of
Faith” (חזוק אמונה), by Isaak ben Abraham Troki (1594), “Vindiciæ
Judæorum,” by Manasseh ben Israel (1650).
In refuting arguments brought by Christians and Mohammedans against
Jews and Judaism, and rejecting the Messianic claims of Jesus and
Mohammed, Jews are ready to acknowledge the good work done by the
religions founded by these men, Christians and Mohammedans, in
combating idolatry and spreading civilisation. Maimonides says as
follows:—“The King Messiah will in some future time come, restore the
kingdom of David to its former power, build the Temple, bring together
the scattered of Israel, and all the ancient laws will again be in
force: sacrifices will be offered, and years of release and Jubilees
will be kept as prescribed in the Law. Whoever does not believe in him,
or does not hope for his coming, shows a want of faith not only in the
Prophets, but also in the Law; for the Law testifies concerning him in
the words: ‘And the Lord thy God will again bring back thy captivity,
show mercy to thee, and again gather thee, &c. If thy outcasts be at
the end of the heavens, thence will the Lord gather thee,’ &c, ‘and the
Lord will bring thee,’ &c. (Deut. xxx. 3–5), &c.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account