And finally, even if we assume that such a wholly unprecedented and
inexplicable incident occurred, how are we to explain the immediate and
wholesale enfranchisement of so large a number? Ransom by wealthy
coreligionists at Rome is excluded by the hypothesis. Similar action by
Jews outside the city would demand a much longer time. The reasons
generally assigned are based upon the assumed uselessness of Jewish
slaves for ordinary purposes because of their dietary laws and religious
intransigeance. But that is a purely dogmatic assertion. Papyri and
inscriptions have shown that in spite of a bitter racial opposition and
perhaps economic strife as well, Jew and non-Jew could live quite
peaceably together. The dietary laws would not render his master’s meals
obnoxious to a Jewish slave, because he did not eat at his master’s
table, and might consume his scanty vegetable food where and how he
pleased. If a master actually chose to force attendance at the
sacrifice, the compulsion of necessity would have been a valid excuse
for all but those of martyr stuff, and we cannot suppose that every
Jewish soldier had in him the zeal of a martyr. Besides, for such
compulsion the slave would in no sense be responsible, and it is with
disadvantages moving from him that we are concerned.
It is simply impossible to imagine what could have induced Pompey’s
soldiers or those who purchased from them to enfranchise immediately
slaves transported from such a distance and at such expense.
Philo’s statement is at best a conjecture, made without any better
acquaintance with the facts than we ourselves possess, and contradicted
by the necessary inference from Cicero’s words.
We must therefore assign the settlement of Jews in Rome to a much
earlier date. The tradition that some of the train of Simon’s embassy
had remained in Rome is, as we have seen, probable enough. To that
nucleus there was added, by a perfectly natural and even inevitable
infiltration, a group of Jewish freedmen, artisans, and merchants who
were establishing themselves all over the Mediterranean. Jews are met
with at Delphi a hundred years before the delivery of this speech.[244]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account