Within a state only those individuals can have relatively free play who
are to a certain extent the organs of the state; that is, those
individuals who by conquest, wealth, or chance have secured for
themselves political predominance in their respective communities. But
these could never be more than a small minority. For the great majority
everyday life was hemmed in by conventions that had the force of laws,
and was restricted by legal limits drastically enforced. And this narrow
and pitifully poor life was bounded by Sheol, or Hades, by a condition
eloquently described as worse at its best than the least desirable
existence under the face of the insufferable sun.[145]
The warrior caste, for whom and of whom the Homeric poems were written,
were firmly convinced that the bloodless and sinewless life in the House
of Hades was the goal to which existence tended. But they found their
compensation in that existence itself. What of those who lacked these
compensations, or had learned to despise them? In them the prospect of
becoming lost in the mass of flitting and indistinguishable shadows must
have produced a profound horror, and their minds must have dwelt upon it
with increasing intensity.
It is one of the most ancient beliefs of men in this region that all the
dead become disembodied spirits, sometimes with power for good or evil,
so that their displeasure is to be deprecated, sometimes without such
power, as the Homeric nobles believed, and the mass of the Jews in the
times of the monarchy. These spirits or ghosts had of themselves no
recognizable personality, and could receive it only exceptionally and in
ways that violated the ordinary laws of the universe. Such a belief is
not strictly a belief in immortality at all, since the essence of the
latter is that the actual person of flesh and blood continues his
identity when flesh and blood are dissolved and disappear, and that the
characteristics which, except for form and feature, separated him from
his fellows in life still do so after death. The only bodiless beings
who could be said to have a personality were the gods, and they were
directly styled “the Immortals.”
However, the line that separated gods and men was not sharp. The
adoration offered to the dead in the Spartan relief[146] is not really
different from the worship of the Olympians. From the other side, in
Homer, the progeny of Zeus by mortal women are very emphatically
men.[147] Whether the Homeric view is a special development, it is
demonstrably true that a general belief was current in Greece not long
after the Homeric epoch, which saw no impossibility in favored men
securing the gift of immortality; that is, continuing without
interruption the personal life which alone had significance. This was
done by the translations—the removal of mortal men in the flesh to
kinship with the gods.[148]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account