The Jews in Great Britain: Being a Series of Six Lectures, Delivered in the Liverpool Collegiate Institution, on the Antiquities of the Jews in England.Margoliouth, Moses
History
The Jews in Great Britain: Being a Series of Six Lectures, Delivered in the Liverpool Collegiate Institution, on the Antiquities of the Jews in England.
Margoliouth, Moses
Jews -- Great Britain -- History
The reason why we are not favoured with more information on their
history in this country, by themselves, has already been hinted at
in the first Lecture.¹ It is certain that the Jews had many valuable
libraries in this country, which were taken from them before they were
driven out of it, and were bestowed on the universities and monasteries.
However, this consideration belongs properly to the second series
of these Lectures, which shall be fully treated when that series is
delivered. Dr. Jost is by no means correct when he says, “There is no
trace of (Jewish) schools in England; no Rabbi of that country occupies
a place in the annals of Jewish scholars; there was no time for study,
and no ambition stimulated and encouraged those who were eager for the
acquirement of knowledge.”² Not only is this statement at variance with
Rabbi Solomon ben Virga’s, but also with his own. He himself says, with
reference to the English Jews, “The learned amongst them prosecuted
the medical sciences, yet more as an art; and they were, through their
acquaintance with some secret means of cures, so celebrated, that the
divines were interrupted in their wonderful cures,” &c.³ Indeed there
are many statements in this historian’s productions, which must be
received with a ♦considerable degree of caution.
¹ See pp. 7–11.
² “_Von Schulen ist keine Spur in England, daher auch nicht
von Gelehrten; kein dortiger Rabbiner hat einen Platz in den
Jüdischen Jahrbüchern der Gelehrten. Zum Studiren war keine
Zeit, und keine Ehre lockte und stärkte den Wissbegierigen_”
――Geschichte der Israeliten, vol. vii., p. 165.
³ For the original refer to Appendix G. of Lecture II.
♦ ‘consirable’ replaced with ‘considerable’
There is, however, a current opinion amongst the modern English Jews,
that especially “the sayings of the wise men of Norwich and of York are
quoted in some of the additions made by the expounders of the Talmud.”¹
I must confess, I cannot vouch for the correctness of that opinion. I
addressed once a letter on this subject to the editor of the “Jewish
Chronicle,”² hoping to elicit from his numerous well-educated readers,
information on the above. The learned editor seems to have mistaken the
purport of my letter to him, and therefore gave an answer not at all to
the purpose. It is the following given in a note:――
¹ See p. 9.
² See Appendix I.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account