The Journal of Prison Discipline and Philanthropy 1919 (New Series, No. 58)Pennsylvania Prison Society
History
The Journal of Prison Discipline and Philanthropy 1919 (New Series, No. 58)
Pennsylvania Prison Society
Charities -- Periodicals; Prisons -- Periodicals
“In times of war severity of treatment, within the limits of
humanity, is to be expected by those who refuse to fulfill
their obligations to the nation; but the term ‘severity of
treatment’ is an euphemism when used to describe the experiences
of conscientious objectors, shackled, unclothed, for hours to
cell doors, kept for days in dark cells, and forced for weeks to
subsist under physical conditions which the law would not permit
in the case of animals. If these charges are substantiated, and
the outraged sense of justice of the nation demands that they be
either substantiated or disproved, then the drastic revision of
military law and practice is an imperative duty of Congress which
it dare not ignore or neglect.
“There is abundant reason to believe, in the severity of the
sentences permitted to be imposed by army courts-martial, that
there is lacking in the military mind that sense of fitness and
of humanity which is in accordance with the age in which we live.
The United States cannot with clean hands ask the nations with
which it is allied in the war to humanize the laws of war while
it tolerates inhumanity in the enforcement of its own military
regulations at home. Recalcitrant soldiers offer a difficult
problem, of course; but the fact is a greater reason for dealing
with such offenders with tact and, above all, with humanity.
Torture has no place in the penology of the day, and least of all
in the service which prides itself on its patriotism.”
The Acting Committee of The Pennsylvania Society, having been informed
of some instances of punishment which seemed to resemble soulless
European autocratic methods, sent the following remonstrance to
Secretary Baker:--
“The Pennsylvania Prison Society learns with astonishment and
a profound sense of sorrow of the brutal methods of punishment
employed in some of our Federal Prisons upon military
offenders--especially upon so-called “Conscientious Objectors”
whose only offense is a consistent adherence to their sense of
duty. The studied attempt to break the spirit of prisoners at
Fort Leavenworth and elsewhere by unspeakable cruelty suggests
the practices of a barbaric past rather than those of a civilized
and enlightened people. Granting that a Nation must at times deal
firmly with political offenders, can any crime ever justify the
employment of cruel and inhumane treatment? If such barbarous
punishment has the sanction of law, then an outraged sense of
justice demands the immediate revision of our Military Code.”
The following note was received, which indicates that the War
Department at Washington has taken measures to relieve the harsh
conditions.
“FEBRUARY 6, 1919.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account