The Journal of Prison Discipline and Philanthropy (New Series, No. 3, January 1864)Philadelphia Society for Alleviating the Miseries of Public Prisons
History
The Journal of Prison Discipline and Philanthropy (New Series, No. 3, January 1864)
Philadelphia Society for Alleviating the Miseries of Public Prisons
Charities -- Periodicals; Prisons -- Periodicals
In a subsequent part of this Report, under the head of “Correspondence,”
will be found large supplemental abstracts of British Parliamentary
Reports; and it is thought that a few words explanatory of the British
and Irish system might, in this part of our Report, be made useful in
aid of the plan for auxiliaries. England has learned much from us in the
work of Prison Discipline: we might learn something of her, (more,
indeed, than we _shall_ acquire,) were our institutions more
assimilated, and especially were we as geographically circumscribed as
she is.
The “Prison Reports,” physical and moral, in Great Britain, are all to
the Government of the nation; and every part of every city jail seems to
work with as distinct a reference to the whole system of prison
regulation as the lower clerkships of a State Department do to the
administration of the whole. This, it must be admitted, is easy in that
country, where there is but one legislature to direct, and one
government to administer and execute. It would be impossible in this
country, for the National Congress to issue ordinances for the
administration of _State_, county, and city prisons. To say nothing of
State rights and State sovereignty, there would be insurmountable
difficulties in prescribing and carrying out rules for prison discipline
and dietaries for all the jails from Oregon to Maine. So that, when we
read of the happy and harmonious working of the prison laws in Ireland
and Great Britain, we must call to mind the proximity of each
establishment to the other, and of the whole to the Government, to whose
chief officers they are bound to make report, and with whose agents they
are bound to co-operate. In England and Ireland the difference of
longitude is so small, that, by the Sovereign’s command, it is made
mid-day at the same moment in both kingdoms. In the United States,
something more than human power would be required to work out that
wonder, and something more than constitutional prerogative would be
necessary to enforce it. We must take things as they are, and work with
the means and in the space which are allowed. If we cannot expect
national interference in behalf of prison discipline, we certainly may
appeal to the State in which we live to exercise and dignify its
sovereignty by legislation that will adapt prisons and their discipline
to the use of society, and while the House is one of penal discipline,
it shall be a place of moral improvement. We scarcely expect the
Legislature of the State to initiate the good work. It is the duty of
those who feel most anxious for its establishment, to prepare the means
and present the arguments; and it is believed that no means of inducing
a systematic arrangement of prison discipline throughout the State
exists outside this Society. Persons abound who see and deplore the
evils of the present want of system, but they lack the full information,
and especially do they lack concurrent action; and it is believed that
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account