The Journal of Speculative Philosophy, Vol. I, Nos. 1-4, 1867Various
Philosophy
The Journal of Speculative Philosophy, Vol. I, Nos. 1-4, 1867
Various
Philosophy -- Periodicals
Such an allegorical foundation could not be developed otherwise than in
huge masses; the division of each mass in itself, so that all the
elements of the thought lying at the bottom should appear, was the
proper object of the composition. The First Part could also be called
allegorical, in so far as it reflected the universal Essence of Spirit
in the Individual; but it could not be said of it in any other sense
than of every poem; Allegory in its stricter sense was not to be found;
the shapes had all flesh and blood, and no design was felt. In the
Second Part everything passes over into the really Allegorical, to which
Goethe, the older he grew, seems to have had the greater inclination;
the _Xenien_, the _Trilogie der Leidenschaft_, the _Lieder zur Loge_,
the _Maskenzüge_, _Epimenides Erwachen_, the cultivation of the Eastern
manners, all proceeded from a didactic turn which delighted in
expressing itself in gnomes, pictures, and symbolical forms. With
wonderful acuteness, Goethe has always been able to seize the
characteristic determinations, and unfold them in neat, living language;
however, it lies in the nature of such poems that they exercise the
reflective faculty more than the heart, and it was easy to foresee that
the Second Part of Faust would never acquire the popularity of the First
Part; that it would not, as the latter, charm the nation, and educate
the people to a consciousness of itself, but that it would always have a
sort of esoteric existence. Many will be repelled by the mythological
learning of the second and third acts; and the more so, as they do not
see themselves recompensed by the dialectic of an action; however, we
would unhesitatingly defend the poet against this reproach; a poem which
has to compass the immeasurable material of the world, cannot be limited
in this respect. What learning has not Dante supposed in his readers?
Humbly have we sought it, in order to acquire an understanding of his
poem, in the certainty of being richly rewarded; the censure which has
been cast upon it for this reason has effected nothing. Indeed, such
fault-finders would here forget what the first acknowledged Part of
Faust has compelled them to learn. With this difference of plan, the
style must also change. Instead of dramatic pathos, because action is
wanting, description, explanation, indication, have become necessary;
and instead of the lively exchange of dialogue, the lyrical portion has
become more prominent, in order to embody with simplicity the elements
of the powerful world-life. The descriptions of nature deserve to be
mentioned in particular. The most wanton fancy, the deepest feeling, the
most accurate knowledge, and the closest observation into the
individual, prevail in all these pictures with an indescribable charm.
We shall now give a short account of the contents of each act. In a more
complete exposition we would point out the places in which the power of
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account