The Journal of Speculative Philosophy, Vol. I, Nos. 1-4, 1867Various
Philosophy
The Journal of Speculative Philosophy, Vol. I, Nos. 1-4, 1867
Various
Philosophy -- Periodicals
3. In fact, independently of the external causes which have occasioned
the _decadence_ of Greek art and precipitated its downfall, many
internal causes, in the very nature of the Greek ideal, rendered that
downfall inevitable. In the first place, the Greek gods, as we have
seen, bear in themselves the germ of their destruction, and the defect
which they conceal is unveiled by the representations of classic art
itself. The plurality of the gods and their diversity makes them already
accidental existences; this multiplicity cannot satisfy reason. Thought
dissolves them and makes them return to a single divinity. Moreover, the
gods do not remain in their eternal repose; they enter into action, take
part in the interests, in the passions, and mingle in the collisions of
human life. The multitude of relations in which they are engaged, as
actors in this drama, destroys their divine majesty; contradicts their
grandeur, their dignity, their beauty. In the true ideal itself, that of
sculpture, we observe something, the inanimate, impassive, cold, a
serious air of silent mournfulness, which indicates that something
higher weighs them down—destiny, supreme unity, blind divinity, the
immutable fate to which gods and men are alike subject.
But the principal cause is, that absolute necessity making no integral
part of their personality, and being foreign to them, the particular
individual side is no longer restrained in its downward course; it is
developed more and more without hindrance and without limit. They suffer
themselves to be drawn into the external accidents of human life, and
fall into all the imperfections of anthropomorphism. Hence the ruin of
these beautiful divinities of art is inevitable. The moral consciousness
turns away from them and rejects them. The gods, it is true, are ethical
persons, but under the human and corporeal form. Now, true morality
appears only in the conscience, and under a purely spiritual form. The
point of view of the beautiful is neither that of religion nor that of
morality. The infinite, invisible spirituality is the divine for the
religious consciousness. For the moral consciousness, the good is an
idea, a conception, an obligation, which commands the sacrifice of
sense. It is in vain, then, to be enthusiastic over Greek art and
beauty, to admire those beautiful divinities. The soul does not
recognize herself wholly in the object of her contemplation or her
worship. What she conceives as the true ideal is a God, spiritual,
infinite, absolute, personal, endowed with moral qualities, with
justice, goodness, etc.
It is this whose image the gods of Greek polytheism, in spite of their
beauty, do not present us.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account