The Journal of Speculative Philosophy, Vol. I, Nos. 1-4, 1867Various
Philosophy
The Journal of Speculative Philosophy, Vol. I, Nos. 1-4, 1867
Various
Philosophy -- Periodicals
Such is the nature of art. If it be asked, what is its end, here we
encounter the most diverse opinions. The most common is that which gives
imitation as its object. This is the foundation of nearly all the
theories upon art. Now of what use to reproduce that which nature
already offers to our view? This puerile talk, unworthy of spirit to
which it is addressed, unworthy of man who produces it, would only end
in the revelation of its impotency and the vanity of its efforts; for
the copy will always remain inferior to the original. Besides, the more
exact the imitation, the less vivid is the pleasure. That which pleases
us is not imitation, but creation. The very least invention surpasses
all the masterpieces of imitation.
In vain is it said that art ought to imitate beautiful Nature. To select
is no longer to imitate. Perfection in imitation is exactness; moreover,
choice supposes a rule; where find the criterion? What signifies, in
fine, imitation in architecture, in music, and even in poetry? At most,
one can thus explain descriptive poetry, that is to say, the most
prosaic kind. We must conclude, therefore, that if, in its compositions,
art employs the forms of Nature, and must study them, its aim is not to
copy and to reproduce them. Its mission is higher—its procedure freer.
Rival of nature, it represents ideas as well as she, and even better; it
uses her forms as symbols to express them; and it fashions even these,
remodels them upon a type more perfect and more pure. It is not without
significance that its works are styled the creations of the genius of
man.
A second system substitutes expression for imitation. Art accordingly
has for its aim, not to represent the external form of things, but their
internal and living principle, particularly the ideas, sentiments,
passions, and conditions of the soul.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account