The journal of the American-Irish Historical Society, Vol. I, 1898Various
History
The journal of the American-Irish Historical Society, Vol. I, 1898
Various
American-Irish Historical Society -- Periodicals; Ethnology -- United States -- Periodicals; Irish Americans -- Periodicals
But Mr. Burgess has a theory, and he does not propose to hamper it
with facts. He asserts that the government—the political
organization—of Spain, Italy, and Portugal are the results of
Teutonic genius. This will probably be news to the world; but if the
debility, decay, and general rottenness of those kingdoms are the
result of Teutonic genius, the sooner they try the genius of the
negro and the Chinaman the better for them. He covers whatever
political good may exist in Greece, Bulgaria, and Roumania by
attributing it to the impecunious German princes now adorning the
rickety thrones in those lands. The idea is original, but not
impressive. Why not attribute the political condition of Scandinavia
to the presence on its throne for ninety years of Bernadotte, the
French (Celtic) military adventurer, and his wife, the daughter of
the Irish merchant Cleary, and their children? The logic is as good,
or as bad, in one case as the other.
But why go on with this tissue of professional rubbish?
Nations are made what they are by climate, environment, peace, war,
and economic and industrial conditions. Groups of men learn as does
the individual, in the school of experience. Nations have no genius
for anything; the botch work we call government to-day at its best
is hardly a manifestation of genius. Nations may have temperaments,
the product of experience, but only the individual has character.
Professor Burgess is merely a mental invalid, an hysterical
Celtophobe. He either forgets the existence of Rome and Greece, or
he fails to understand the value of civilization and human
experience; he is a kind of literary phonograph, repeating the
slanders and absurdities which a school of race egotists have raised
to a cult. He is a decidedly unsafe man to educate a coming
generation of Americans, for the writer of solemn and dogmatic
nonsense is unfit to train the American youth. Certainly no
self-respecting man of Irish-Celtic blood should permit his children
to attend a university where they are taught that the perpetrators
of ages of outrage and wrong are divinely selected beings, chosen
“to assume leadership in the establishment and administration of
States.”
If we desire that sort of rubbish taught, it is just as easy to
secure professors at Bloomingdale as it is at Columbia.
The legendary and sentimental makers of history seem to thrive best
in New England; and a fine type of the cult is the so-called
“scholar in politics,” Senator Henry Cabot Lodge, of Massachusetts
and Nahant. There is in China a religion whose principal tenet is
the worship of ancestors, the placation of ancestral manes. This
religion is called Tavism; and possibly the purest type of Tavist,
outside of China, is the junior senator from Massachusetts.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account